Table 1.
References | Study Type | NMP device | Donor type | N° graft NMP vs. SCS | Graft Survival at 180/365 days NMP vs. SCS | Patient Survival at 180/365 days NMP vs. SCS | Median AST peak 7 days |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ravikumar et al. (46) | Observational | OrganOx metra® | DBD + DCD | 20 vs. 39 | 180 days: 100% vs. 97.5% | 180 days: 100% vs. 97.5% | 417 vs. 902 |
Perera et al. (45) | Observational | OrganOx metra® | DCD | 1 vs. 0 | 365 days: 100% | 365 days: 100% | NA |
Mergental et al. (47) | Observational | OrganOx metra® | DBD+DCD | 5 vs. 0 | 180 days: 100% | NA | NA |
Bral et al. (49) | Nonrandomized pilot study | OrganOx metra® | DBD+DCD | 10 vs. 30 | 180 days: 80% vs. 100% | 180 days: 89% vs. 100% | 1,252 vs. 839 |
Nasralla et al. (50) | RCT | OrganOx metra® | DBD+DCD | 121 vs. 101 | 365 days: 95% vs. 96% | 365 days: 94.9 vs. 95.8% | 167.5 vs. 318.5 |
Ghinolfi et al. (53) | RCT | Liver Assist® | DBD | 10 vs. 10 | 180 days: 90% vs. 90% | 180 days: 100% vs. 90% | 709 vs. 574 |
RCT, randomized controlled trial; DBD, donor brain death; DCD, donor cardiac death; SCS, static cold storage; AST, aspartate aminotransferase.