Skip to main content
. 2020 Sep 15;10(11):4177–4190. doi: 10.1534/g3.120.401631

Table 2. Prediction performance of data set 1 in terms of mean square error (MSE), mean arctangent absolute percentage error (MAAPE) and Average Pearson Correlation (APC) without taking into consideration genotype×environment interaction (WI) and taking it into account (I) in the 13 models. SE_1 denotes the standard error of the MSE, SE_2 denotes the standard error of the MAAPE and SE_3 denotes the standard error of the APC.

Model Interaction Trait MSE SE_1 MAAPE SE_2 APC SE_3
UPDN_1 WI y1 49.792 7.579 0.596 0.024 0.546 0.054
UPDN_1 WI y2 51.319 7.742 0.662 0.015 0.523 0.06
Average 50.556 7.661 0.629 0.020 0.535 0.057
UPDN_2 WI y1 46.03 4.51 0.607 0.023 0.55 0.043
UPDN_2 WI y2 46.611 7.902 0.668 0.024 0.535 0.067
Average 46.321 6.206 0.638 0.024 0.543 0.055
UPDN_3 WI y1 46.08 4.969 0.623 0.021 0.553 0.048
UPDN_3 WI y2 48.441 6.686 0.681 0.021 0.524 0.061
Average 47.261 5.828 0.652 0.021 0.539 0.055
UPDN_4 WI y1 44.609 5.645 0.625 0.018 0.554 0.032
UPDN_4 WI y2 49.637 7.102 0.673 0.015 0.523 0.078
Average 47.123 6.374 0.649 0.017 0.539 0.055
MPDN_1 WI y1 45.507 10.464 0.581 0.047 0.87 0.025
MPDN_1 WI y2 37.971 9.21 0.583 0.048 0.865 0.026
Average 41.739 9.837 0.582 0.048 0.868 0.026
MPDN_2 WI y1 45.294 10.069 0.591 0.048 0.863 0.026
MPDN_2 WI y2 36.453 9.294 0.582 0.049 0.86 0.027
Average 40.874 9.682 0.587 0.049 0.862 0.027
MPDN_3 WI y1 48.682 10.454 0.595 0.048 0.854 0.027
MPDN_3 WI y2 39.857 8.977 0.612 0.047 0.853 0.028
Average 44.270 9.716 0.604 0.048 0.854 0.028
MPDN_4 WI y1 49.999 10.283 0.625 0.046 0.831 0.031
MPDN_4 WI y2 41.182 8.96 0.614 0.048 0.834 0.031
Average 45.591 9.622 0.620 0.047 0.833 0.031
GPR_L1_0.5 WI y1 39.964 8.811 0.583 0.047 0.889 0.022
GPR_L1_0.5 WI y2 36.945 9.926 0.592 0.048 0.861 0.025
Average 38.455 9.369 0.588 0.048 0.875 0.024
GPR_L1_0.25 WI y1 36.732 7.982 0.577 0.047 0.896 0.021
GPR_L1_0.25 WI y2 35.138 9.154 0.592 0.049 0.867 0.025
Average 35.935 8.568 0.585 0.048 0.882 0.023
GPR_L1_0.75 WI y1 41.012 9.051 0.583 0.047 0.886 0.022
GPR_L1_0.75 WI y2 37.738 10.202 0.592 0.049 0.859 0.026
Average 39.375 9.627 0.588 0.048 0.873 0.024
GPR_Lassso WI y1 41.99 9.299 0.585 0.047 0.884 0.023
GPR_Lassso WI y2 37.958 10.251 0.592 0.048 0.858 0.026
Average 39.974 9.775 0.589 0.048 0.871 0.025
GPR_Ridge WI y1 33.521 7.205 0.57 0.048 0.905 0.02
GPR_Ridge WI y2 33.701 8.817 0.594 0.049 0.888 0.02
Average 33.611 8.011 0.582 0.049 0.897 0.020
UPDN_1 I y1 133.047 7.442 0.695 0.024 0.373 0.055
UPDN_1 I y2 99.26 11.279 0.711 0.021 0.402 0.05
Average 116.154 9.361 0.703 0.023 0.388 0.053
UPDN_2 I y1 95.62 7.786 0.669 0.025 0.409 0.053
UPDN_2 I y2 75.986 11.879 0.691 0.019 0.389 0.051
Average 85.803 9.833 0.680 0.022 0.399 0.052
UPDN_3 I y1 97.618 6.255 0.687 0.023 0.389 0.064
UPDN_3 I y2 72.15 9.406 0.698 0.017 0.397 0.051
Average 84.884 7.831 0.693 0.020 0.393 0.058
UPDN_4 I y1 102.29 7.787 0.679 0.02 0.346 0.061
UPDN_4 I y2 74.66 12.035 0.7 0.014 0.356 0.057
Average 88.475 9.911 0.690 0.017 0.351 0.059
MPDN_1 I y1 111.247 23.885 0.662 0.044 0.766 0.04
MPDN_1 I y2 102.691 23.825 0.668 0.044 0.758 0.043
Average 106.969 23.855 0.665 0.044 0.762 0.042
MPDN_2 I y1 98.646 21.658 0.653 0.046 0.782 0.041
MPDN_2 I y2 90.899 21.828 0.643 0.046 0.771 0.04
Average 94.773 21.743 0.648 0.046 0.777 0.041
MPDN_3 I y1 96.984 21.958 0.66 0.046 0.766 0.042
MPDN_3 I y2 89.359 22.391 0.638 0.047 0.769 0.041
Average 93.172 22.175 0.649 0.047 0.768 0.042
MPDN_4 I y1 94.62 21.06 0.651 0.046 0.779 0.039
MPDN_4 I y2 85.397 21.374 0.632 0.047 0.78 0.038
Average 90.009 21.217 0.642 0.047 0.780 0.039
GPR_L1_0.5 I y1 64.279 14.495 0.624 0.046 0.825 0.031
GPR_L1_0.5 I y2 48.417 10.777 0.623 0.048 0.783 0.04
Average 56.348 12.636 0.624 0.047 0.804 0.036
GPR_L1_0.25 I y1 62.199 13.912 0.61 0.046 0.83 0.03
GPR_L1_0.25 I y2 46.086 10.418 0.621 0.048 0.787 0.04
Average 54.143 12.165 0.616 0.047 0.809 0.035
GPR_L1_0.75 I y1 65.515 14.917 0.627 0.045 0.824 0.032
GPR_L1_0.75 I y2 49.455 11.066 0.624 0.048 0.781 0.039
Average 57.485 12.992 0.626 0.047 0.803 0.036
GPR_Lassso I y1 67.005 15.7 0.628 0.046 0.82 0.033
GPR_Lassso I y2 50.073 11.395 0.624 0.048 0.78 0.04
Average 58.539 13.548 0.626 0.047 0.800 0.037
GPR_Ridge I y1 116.056 22.719 0.788 0.049 0.857 0.028
GPR_Ridge I y2 86.785 18.019 0.775 0.049 0.826 0.032
Average 101.421 20.369 0.782 0.049 0.842 0.030