Skip to main content
. 2020 Sep 15;10(11):4177–4190. doi: 10.1534/g3.120.401631

Table 3. Prediction performance of data set 2 in terms of mean square error (MSE), mean arctangent absolute percentage error (MAAPE) and Average Pearson Correlation (APC) without taking into consideration the genotype×environment interaction (WI) and taking it into account (I) in the 13 models. SE_1 denotes the standard error of the MSE, SE_2 denotes the standard error of the MAAPE and SE_3 denotes the standard error of the APC.

Model Interaction Trait MSE SE_1 MAAPE SE_2 APC SE_3
UPDN_1 WI PTR 16.682 3.268 0.503 0.025 0.371 0.045
UPDN_1 WI SB 9.640 0.816 0.408 0.019 0.408 0.029
UPDN_1 WI SN 10.965 1.144 0.350 0.016 0.552 0.037
Average 12.429 1.743 0.420 0.020 0.444 0.037
UPDN_2 WI PTR 11.323 1.172 0.438 0.019 0.458 0.039
UPDN_2 WI SB 8.244 0.671 0.383 0.021 0.449 0.041
UPDN_2 WI SN 8.786 0.716 0.306 0.014 0.622 0.032
Average 9.451 0.853 0.376 0.018 0.510 0.037
UPDN_3 WI PTR 12.444 1.38 0.462 0.023 0.458 0.043
UPDN_3 WI SB 7.833 0.562 0.379 0.016 0.467 0.044
UPDN_3 WI SN 8.542 0.621 0.313 0.014 0.634 0.033
Average 9.606 0.854 0.385 0.018 0.520 0.040
UPDN_4 WI PTR 10.651 0.863 0.421 0.022 0.492 0.032
UPDN_4 WI SB 7.382 0.493 0.373 0.018 0.487 0.038
UPDN_4 WI SN 8.364 0.835 0.294 0.015 0.64 0.034
Average 8.799 0.730 0.363 0.018 0.540 0.035
MPDN_1 WI SN 8.287 0.815 0.300 0.015 0.644 0.031
MPDN_1 WI PTR 11.433 0.892 0.438 0.019 0.514 0.034
MPDN_1 WI SB 8.060 0.683 0.380 0.016 0.474 0.038
Average 9.260 0.797 0.373 0.017 0.544 0.034
MPDN_2 WI SN 8.362 0.816 0.292 0.015 0.649 0.031
MPDN_2 WI PTR 10.523 0.791 0.429 0.019 0.538 0.033
MPDN_2 WI SB 7.357 0.572 0.369 0.016 0.482 0.037
Average 8.747 0.726 0.363 0.017 0.556 0.034
MPDN_3 WI SN 8.312 0.790 0.304 0.015 0.656 0.030
MPDN_3 WI PTR 10.252 0.801 0.420 0.019 0.544 0.033
MPDN_3 WI SB 7.616 0.564 0.375 0.016 0.460 0.038
Average 8.727 0.718 0.366 0.017 0.553 0.034
MPDN_4 WI SN 8.233 0.796 0.278 0.015 0.653 0.030
MPDN_4 WI PTR 10.371 0.778 0.422 0.019 0.528 0.033
MPDN_4 WI SB 7.855 0.593 0.372 0.016 0.449 0.038
Average 8.820 0.722 0.357 0.017 0.543 0.034
GPR_L1_0.5 WI SN 8.389 0.787 0.304 0.015 0.630 0.031
GPR_L1_0.5 WI PTR 10.139 0.769 0.408 0.019 0.535 0.033
GPR_L1_0.5 WI SB 7.168 0.555 0.371 0.016 0.482 0.037
Average 8.565 0.704 0.361 0.017 0.549 0.034
GPR_L1_0.25 WI SN 8.384 0.786 0.304 0.015 0.631 0.031
GPR_L1_0.25 WI PTR 10.132 0.769 0.408 0.019 0.534 0.033
GPR_L1_0.25 WI SB 7.163 0.556 0.371 0.016 0.483 0.037
Average 8.560 0.704 0.361 0.017 0.549 0.034
GPR_L1_0.75 WI SN 8.389 0.787 0.304 0.015 0.631 0.031
GPR_L1_0.75 WI PTR 10.140 0.769 0.408 0.019 0.535 0.033
GPR_L1_0.75 WI SB 7.170 0.555 0.371 0.016 0.482 0.037
Average 8.566 0.704 0.361 0.017 0.549 0.034
GPR_Lassso WI SN 8.390 0.787 0.304 0.015 0.631 0.031
GPR_Lassso WI PTR 10.140 0.769 0.408 0.019 0.535 0.033
GPR_Lassso WI SB 7.171 0.556 0.371 0.016 0.482 0.037
Average 8.567 0.704 0.361 0.017 0.549 0.034
GPR_Ridge WI SN 8.346 0.785 0.303 0.015 0.627 0.032
GPR_Ridge WI PTR 10.262 0.767 0.413 0.019 0.512 0.035
GPR_Ridge WI SB 7.159 0.552 0.372 0.016 0.479 0.038
Average 8.589 0.701 0.363 0.017 0.539 0.035
UPDN_1 I PTR 16.213 1.677 0.503 0.024 0.326 0.047
UPDN_1 I SB 10.089 0.923 0.404 0.021 0.361 0.044
UPDN_1 I SN 12.308 1.113 0.353 0.019 0.494 0.051
Average 12.870 1.238 0.420 0.021 0.394 0.047
UPDN_2 I PTR 13.014 1.308 0.45 0.018 0.391 0.046
UPDN_2 I SB 9.448 0.766 0.382 0.016 0.396 0.046
UPDN_2 I SN 10.923 1.016 0.322 0.014 0.562 0.038
Average 11.128 1.030 0.385 0.016 0.450 0.043
UPDN_3 I PTR 13.346 1.472 0.456 0.019 0.43 0.045
UPDN_3 I SB 9.061 0.598 0.384 0.015 0.431 0.04
UPDN_3 I SN 10.718 1.042 0.323 0.018 0.575 0.047
Average 11.042 1.037 0.388 0.017 0.479 0.044
UPDN_4 I PTR 12.421 1.364 0.434 0.021 0.441 0.046
UPDN_4 I SB 8.028 0.62 0.372 0.016 0.451 0.039
UPDN_4 I SN 9.317 0.913 0.309 0.019 0.62 0.035
Average 9.922 0.966 0.372 0.019 0.504 0.040
MPDN_1 I SN 11.878 1.120 0.338 0.014 0.535 0.035
MPDN_1 I PTR 15.276 1.231 0.487 0.018 0.391 0.040
MPDN_1 I SB 10.068 0.776 0.400 0.015 0.370 0.041
Average 12.407 1.042 0.408 0.016 0.432 0.039
MPDN_2 I SN 11.503 1.044 0.323 0.014 0.595 0.031
MPDN_2 I PTR 12.745 1.017 0.440 0.018 0.473 0.037
MPDN_2 I SB 9.341 0.718 0.379 0.015 0.427 0.038
Average 11.196 0.926 0.381 0.016 0.498 0.035
MPDN_3 I SN 9.942 0.896 0.310 0.015 0.585 0.033
MPDN_3 I PTR 11.654 0.910 0.424 0.019 0.471 0.037
MPDN_3 I SB 8.226 0.622 0.375 0.016 0.425 0.038
Average 9.941 0.809 0.370 0.017 0.494 0.036
MPDN_4 I SN 10.314 0.914 0.297 0.015 0.589 0.033
MPDN_4 I PTR 12.018 0.933 0.418 0.019 0.462 0.036
MPDN_4 I SB 8.245 0.616 0.373 0.016 0.423 0.039
Average 10.192 0.821 0.363 0.017 0.491 0.036
GPR_L1_0.5 I SN 10.649 0.884 0.365 0.014 0.527 0.036
GPR_L1_0.5 I PTR 11.539 0.864 0.434 0.018 0.462 0.035
GPR_L1_0.5 I SB 8.482 0.622 0.400 0.016 0.347 0.040
Average 10.223 0.790 0.400 0.016 0.445 0.037
GPR_L1_0.25 I SN 10.661 0.883 0.366 0.014 0.526 0.036
GPR_L1_0.25 I PTR 11.542 0.866 0.435 0.018 0.462 0.035
GPR_L1_0.25 I SB 8.488 0.623 0.400 0.016 0.347 0.040
Average 10.230 0.791 0.400 0.016 0.445 0.037
GPR_L1_0.75 I SN 10.654 0.886 0.365 0.014 0.528 0.036
GPR_L1_0.75 I PTR 11.557 0.865 0.434 0.018 0.460 0.035
GPR_L1_0.75 I SB 8.475 0.621 0.400 0.016 0.347 0.040
Average 10.229 0.791 0.400 0.016 0.445 0.037
GPR_Lassso I SN 10.652 0.886 0.365 0.014 0.528 0.036
GPR_Lassso I PTR 11.553 0.865 0.434 0.018 0.460 0.035
GPR_Lassso I SB 8.490 0.622 0.401 0.016 0.347 0.040
Average 10.232 0.791 0.400 0.016 0.445 0.037
GPR_Ridge I SN 11.722 0.962 0.395 0.013 0.601 0.033
GPR_Ridge I PTR 11.986 0.885 0.438 0.018 0.503 0.035
GPR_Ridge I SB 8.444 0.659 0.386 0.015 0.461 0.038
Average 10.717 0.835 0.406 0.015 0.522 0.035