Table 3.
Epidemiologic studies evaluating dialysate calcium and cardiovascular outcomes
| Study | N | Population | Outcomes | Major Results | Strengths | Limitations |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nappi33, 1999 | 12 | Single-center | Echocardiography | Impaired ventricular relaxation with D-Ca 1.75 mM compared to 1.50 mM or 1.25 mM | Pre/post HD echocardiograms measurements; D-Ca only variable | Small study |
| Nappi34, 2000 | 23 | Single-center | QTc dispersion | Increased QTc dispersion with D-Ca 1.25 mM compared to 1.50 mM or 1.75 mM | Pre/post HD examination; D-Ca only variable | Small study |
| Severi35, 2008 | 23 | Single-center | QTc dispersion | Increased QTc dispersion with D-Ca 1.25 mM vs 2.00 mM | Pre/post HD with electrical modeling | Small study |
| Genovesi36, 2008 | 16 | Single-center | Holter monitor | Increased QTc with D-Ca 1.25 mM compared to 1.50 mM or 1.75 mM | Randomized design | Variation of both calcium and potassium |
| Di Iorio37, 2012 | 22 | Single-center pilot study | Hourly ECG | Prolongation of QTc with low D-Ca/low K/high bicarbonate | Randomized controlled crossover with blinding | Simultaneous variation of calcium, potassium and bicarbonate |
| Pun39, 2013 | 2,070 | DaVita | Sudden cardiac arrest | OR 2.00 for D-Ca < 2.5 mEq/L OR 1.40 per 1 mEq/L of serum-to-dialysate gradient | Large provider database | Total calcium only; Case-control design |
| Brunelli40, 2015 | 353 (facilities) | DaVita | Death, CV death, CHF Hosp, afib, MACE, fracture, Hypocalcemia, HD hypotension | ↑ CHF hosp, hypocalcemia, and HD hypotension with lower D-Ca. No changes in death or CV death | Large provider database | Facility-level data |
D-Ca, Dialysate calcium; ECG, electrocardiogram; HD, hemodialysis; OR, odds ratio; CV, cardiovascular; MACE, major adverse cardiac event (MACE); CHF Hosp, congestive heart failure hospitalization