Table 1.
Characteristics of controlled preclinical studies of human MSC-derived EVs to treat or prevent GVHD in mice
| Study | Model | n* I / C | MSC source | Mouse GVHD induction and confirmation | EV Isolation | EV Characterization | Intervention | Dose of EV (per animal unless stated) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| [23] | Treatment | 30 / 32 | hBM |
8 Gy TBI and tail vein injection of spleen cells from allogeneic mice GVHD confirmation: ≥10% loss of body weight |
UCa |
EV size: 90–400 nm Mean protein: 4.48 mg/ml Particles: 4.23 × 109 /ml EM: Yes Western blot: CD63, CD81 |
Treatment: once on day +5 Route: tail vein |
Controls: saline MSC-EV group: EVs derived from 2 × 106 MSC per kg of body weight |
| [24] | Treatment | 8 / 8 | hBM |
TBI and tail vein injection of BM and spleen cells of allogeneic mice GVHD confirmation: clinical score ≥ 0.6 and molecular donor chimerism on day 20 |
UCb |
EV size: <100 nm Mean protein:: NR Particles: NR EM: Yes Western blot: CD63, CD9, CD81 |
Treatment: Weekly × 6 weeks starting day +22 Route: tail vein |
Controls: saline or 100 μg fibroblast EVs MSC-EV group: 100 μg |
| [25] | Prevention | 20 / 20 | hESC |
TBI 100 cGy and tail vein injection of human PBMC. Human engraftment confirmation: % human cells in blood by flow cytometry |
0.22 μ filter then TFF |
EV size: NR Mean protein:: 1.9 mg/mL Particles: 1.9 × 1011 /mL EM: NR Western blot: NR |
Prophylaxis: every 3 days starting day +1 until death or day +34 Route: intraperitoneal |
Control: saline MSC-EV group: 1 or 10 μg |
| [26] | Prevention | 14 / 15 | hUCB |
TBI 7.5 Gy and tail vein injection of BM and splenocytes allogeneic mice Allogenic engraftment confirmation: NR |
UCc |
EV size: 30–100 nm Mean protein: protein concentration by bicinchoninic acid. Protein concentration NR. Particles: NR EM: Yes Western blot: CD63, CD9, CD81 |
Prophylaxis: day 0 and day +7 Route: tail vein |
Control: no prophylaxis MSC-EV group: 200 μg |
*n = total number of mice included in control and treatment groups and reported as part of primary survival outcome data
I/C intervention / control groups
UC Ultracentrifugation, TFF Tangential flow, NR Not reported
aisolation involved centrifugation at 2000 g × 30 min, 0.22 μfiltration, Total Exosome Isolation Reagent (Invitrogen/Thermo Fisher Scientific), followed by centrifugation at 100,000 g × 1 h
bisolation involved centrifugation at 200 g × 10 min, 2000 g × 20 min, 10,000 g × 30 min, 110,000 g × 7 h then 0.22 μfiltration and repeating all steps again
cisolation involved centrifugation at 2000 g × 30 min followed by centrifugation at 100,000 g × 2 h and repeated