Table 2.
Included papers, considerations, and emerging governance trends.
| Reference | Country | Experience and performance (descriptive) | Considerations and suggested improvements (descriptive) | Trends and emerging governance models |
| Atalag K, 2013 [14] | New Zealand | Suggesting a “middle out” approach; a single top-down approach does not produce the expected outcome; success relies on a relationship based on trust between the authorities and the medical society | The national Single Content Model is flexible and “enables smooth transition to a comprehensive solution through gradual replacement over time” | The openEHR trend and Archetypes; governance based upon a top-down strategy for interoperability |
| Park YT, 2015 [15] | New Zealand | Strong top-down governance strategy and organizational structures and rules has been the most important factors for successful eHealth governance | Next steps will be to analyze how the eHealth structure influence health outcomes and minimize errors | Strong belief in strong government involvement leads to successful goal attainment in eHealth |
| De Riel E, 2018 [17] | Haiti | A key learning is leadership engagement to create an understanding of how the system works | Haiti’s health care service is dependent on national and third-party funding; realizing a sustainable information and technology communications infrastructure is a muddle-through process | System migration to the OpenMRS platform to take advantage of a global community and ensure sustainability |
| Kierkegaard P, 2015 [16] | Denmark | Setting national goals and adapting the middle-out approach as part of a national strategy is the best way to realize full-scale implementation of electronic health records, an approach based on cross-regional coordination | A collective phase-out of all systems may be costly, but it may be the only way to create a common national platform of high interoperability; risk of regions working with one vendor, which creates regional dependency on an actor with market monopoly | The Danish framework is flexible and in line with the European Union eHealth Interoperability framework |
| Wade VA, 2012 [18] | Australia | This study indicates that telehealth can be a tool to realize medical quality of care governed bottom-up and in line with evidence-based medicine | The medico-legal aspects did not seem to be as difficult as anticipated; national reimbursement schemes may increase substantial system benefits | N/Aa |
| Crocker M, 2010 [19] | United Kingdom | Image transfer is delayed by an immature technology infrastructure | Bottom-up recommendations from the teleradiology society in United Kingdom has been ignored by the top-down process | N/A |
| Sutton LN, 2011 [20] | United Kingdom | Creation of a UK reporting “Grid” with remaining organizational and governance challenges | Telehealth challenges around “team organisation” when the reporter and doctor are in separate organizations at a distance | Creation of a medical governance model in radiology across the United Kingdom which harmonize with the national top-down strategy of National Health Services |
| Bagot KL, 2017 [21] | Australia and United Kingdom | UK model: telemedicine integrated in the specialist work plan; Australia telemedicine was ad hoc | Both networks see telemedicine as part of future organization; can reduce workload by a “follow-the-sun model” | N/A |
| Mackey TK, 2014: (A call for a mora-torium) [22] | Global | The governance of health-related internet domains should be run by international organizations and not by a for-profit company like Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers, which does not respond to actors who want this policy change | The international society should stop the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers governance model | Is it feasible to realize a global internet governance model based on international interstate cooperation? |
| Mackey TK, 2014 [23] | Global | The governance model of dot-health and other internet health domains is not run by the World Health Organization or another international health organization, which may represent a global threat to public health: access to evidence-based medicine and quality assured health information | The main challenge is to realize a shift from a privately-run model to an international model governed by legitimate international public health actors | The combination of internet and global markets challenges political and medical governance |
| Williams, SJ, 2015 [24] | Global | Health apps are a growing trend that realizes “the quantified self”: blurring the lines between health care and wellness through data sharing | N/A | “Quantified-self” apps contribute to a growth of health and wellness data; a “global health and wellness data governance model”? |
aN/A: not applicable.