Table 4.
Finding | Cardiovascular disease | Type 2 diabetes | Total (n) | |||
No. of studies | Reference | No. of studies | Reference | |||
Target population | ||||||
|
General population | 1 | [24] | —a | — | 1 |
|
At risk of the disease | 2 | [23,25] | 6 | [26-31] | 8 |
Location | ||||||
|
Spain | 1 | [24] | — | — | 1 |
|
United States | 1 | [23] | 4 | [27-30] | 5 |
|
Germany | — | — | 1 | [26] | 1 |
|
Latin America | 1 | [25] | — | — | 1 |
|
India | — | — | 1 | [31] | 1 |
Intervention delivery | ||||||
|
SMS text messaging | 2 | [23,25] | 2 | [29,31] | 4 |
|
1 | [24] | — | — | 1 | |
|
Mobile app | — | — | 4 | [26-28,30] | 4 |
Comparator | ||||||
|
Usual care | 3 | [23-25] | 3 | [26,29,31] | 6 |
|
Waitlist | — | — | 2 | [27,28] | 2 |
|
Pedometer only | — | — | 1 | [30] | 1 |
|
Face-to-face training | 1 | [24] | — | — | 1 |
Outcomesb | ||||||
|
Weight loss | 1 | [25] | 3 | [27,28,30] | 4 |
|
Reduced BMI | 1 | [25] | 3 | [27,28,30] | 4 |
|
Reduced waist circumference | — | — | 2 | [27,28] | 2 |
|
Lower fasting blood glucose/glycated hemoglobin | N/Ac | — | 1 | [28] | 1 |
|
Improved diet | 2 | [23,25] | 1 | [31] | 3 |
|
Improved physical activity | — | — | 2 | [30,31] | 2 |
|
Improved blood pressure | — | — | 1 | [30] | 1 |
Study design | ||||||
|
Randomized controlled trial | 1 | [25] | 5 | [27-31] | 6 |
|
Nonrandomized controlled trial | 2 | [23,24] | 1 | [26] | 3 |
a—: data not available.
bStatistically significant compared with control group.
cN/A: not applicable.