Skip to main content
. 2020 Oct 30;7:596007. doi: 10.3389/fmed.2020.596007

Table 2.

Subgroup analyses.

Subgroups VAS DAS28 Serum vitamin D TJC SJC ESR CRP PTH
WMD 95% CI P WMD 95% CI P WMD 95% CI P WMD 95% CI P WMD 95% CI P WMD 95% CI P WMD 95% CI P WMD 95% CI P
Geographical regions
North America 22.26 [−6.97, 51.49] 0.14 −1.00 [−10.19, 8.19] 0.83
Europe −9.26 [−14.51, −4.00] 0.0006 −0.54 [−0.74, −0.34] <0.001 20.35 [9.79, 30.91] 0.0002 −0.90 [−2.65, 0.85] 0.31 −0.50 [−1.68, 0.68] 0.41 −3.25 [−8.94, 2.43] 0.26 −0.31 [−3.71, 3.09] 0.86 6.40 [−0.10, 12.90] 0.05
Asia 6.47 [0.13, 12.82] 0.05 0.07 [−0.31, 0.46] 0.71 26.50 [15.98, 37.02] <0.001 −2.10 [−4.04, −0.16] 0.03 −1.00 [−2.17, 0.17] 0.10 −2.40 [−6.30, 1.50] 0.23 −7.50 [−17.75, 2.75] 0.15
Duration
≤ 12 w −0.86 [−5.53, 3.82] 0.72 −0.06 [−0.28, 0.17] 0.63 23.37 [16.15, 30.59] <0.001 −1.44 [−2.74, −0.14] 0.03 −0.75 [−1.58, 0.08] 0.08 −2.44 [−6.14, 1.25] 0.20 −1.04 [−5.07, 2.99] 0.61 3.94 [−1.37, 9.24] 0.15
>12 w −8.90 [−17.02, −0.78] 0.03 −1.00 [−1.29, −0.71] <0.001 −3.40 [−9.93, 3.13] 0.31 −1.00 [−6.38, 4.38] 0.72
Vitamin D dose
≤ 50,000 IU 6.47 [0.13, 12.82] 0.05 0.07 [−0.31, 0.46] 0.71 26.01 [16.12, 35.91] <0.001 −2.10 [−4.04, −0.16] −0.03 −1.00 [−2.17, 0.17] 0.10 −2.40 [−6.30, 1.50] 0.23 −7.50 [−17.75, 2.75] 0.15 −1.00 [−10.19, 8.19] 0.83
>50,000 IU −9.26 [−14.51, −4.00] 0.0006 −0.54 [−0.74, −0.34] <0.001 20.35 [9.79, 30.91] 0.0002 −0.90 [−2.65, 0.85] 0.31 −0.50 [−1.68, 0.68] 0.41 −3.25 [−8.94, 2.43] 0.26 −0.31 [−3.71, 3.09] 0.86 6.40 [−0.10, 12.90] 0.05