Table 2.
Non-biomedical factors influencing outpatient and community antibiotic use for common community-acquired infections
| Non-biomedical factors | Application/examples | Inappropriate antibiotic use (including prevention use) |
|
| Antibiotic use behaviour outcomes | References | ||
| Knowledge | |||
| General knowledge about antibiotics/AMR | Combined knowledge score Inadequate diagnostic knowledge of doctors Misconceptions (eg, antibiotic is an anti-inflammatory drug) |
Asking/pressuring doctors for antibiotics Self-medication with antibiotics Storing antibiotics at home Taking antibiotics as prophylaxis Healthcare seeking behaviour The likelihood to be prescribed with antibiotics by doctors Combined behaviour score |
14 17 25 36 46 63 |
| Literacy | Being able to recognise antibiotics Knowing when/how to use antibiotics |
No evidence available to date | – |
| Knowledge about the infection | The participant’s knowledge about the specific infection (eg, URTI symptoms will dissipate naturally) | No evidence available to date | – |
| AMR awareness | The participant’s awareness of AMR as a health threat on individual or on the society as a whole | No evidence available to date | – |
| Attitudes | |||
| Attitudes towards antibiotic misuse behaviours | The participant’s accepting attitudes towards storing/self-medicating with antibiotics | Self-medication with antibiotics Storing antibiotics at home |
28 52 |
| Self-efficacy | The participant’s perception of his/her or others’ competence in engaging in caring for the infection or in antibiotic use | No evidence available to date | – |
| Medical background | The participants or their family members having some level of medical education | Asking/pressuring doctors for antibiotics Self-medication with antibiotics Over-the-counter purchases Storing antibiotics at home Taking antibiotics as prophylaxis The likelihood to be prescribed with antibiotics by doctors Combined behaviour score |
13 19 20 28 34 40 41 43 44 47–51 |
| Prior experience | Participants use of antibiotics on previous occasions | Over-the-counter purchase | 76 |
| Perceptions | |||
| Perceived susceptibility | Self-rated health status | Self-medication with antibiotics Combined behaviour score |
28 46 63 |
| Perceived severity | The participant’s assessment/perception of the severity of the situation regarding the infection (eg, self-diagnosed symptoms experienced) The participant’s perception of potential harm of over-the-counter purchase |
Over-the-counter purchase | 32 |
| Perceived benefits and disbenefits | The participant’s mistaken understanding of antibiotics (eg, considering antibiotics as Xiaoyanyao, anti-inflammatory drugs) (misconceptions) | Asking/pressuring doctors for antibiotics Self-medication with antibiotics Taking antibiotics as prophylaxis |
36 |
| Perceived barriers | The participant’s assessment/perception of barriers to engaging in antibiotic use (health insurance and knowledge of current policy) | Self-medication with antibiotics Healthcare seeking behaviour |
14 28 |
| Family dynamics | Family members who might influence the healthcare decisions of caregiver or the patients | Self-medication with antibiotics | 28 45 |
| Doctor–patient relationships | Having a regular doctor Following all the advice from physicians |
Asking/pressuring doctors for antibiotics Self-medication with antibiotics |
18 30 |
| Access to antibiotics | Access to antibiotics, with or without prescription | ||
| Access to non-prescription antibiotics | Over-the-counter purchase Antibiotics stored at home Leftover prescriptions |
Self-medication with antibiotics Taking antibiotics as prophylaxis |
17 18 28 31 41 42 46 50 51 |
| Access to antibiotic prescriptions | Asking/pressuring doctors for antibiotics The education level, training, specialty or seniority of the doctors |
The likelihood to be prescribed with antibiotics by doctors | 22–24 |
| Cues to action | External trigger mechanisms to prompt engagement in antibiotic use behaviour | ||
| Symptoms | Presence of fever | No evidence available to date | – |
| Information sources and seeking for therapeutic purposes decisions | Expectation for antibiotic use knowledge | Combined behaviour score | 63 |
| Socio-contextual factors | |||
| Age | The age of the participant or caregiver | Asking/pressuring doctors for antibiotics Self-medication with antibiotics Over-the-counter purchase Storing antibiotics at home Taking antibiotics as prophylaxis Healthcare seeking behaviour The likelihood to be prescribed with antibiotics by doctors (oral, intravenous or both) Combined behaviour score |
13 14 18–20 32 40 41 45 47 48 50 51 76 |
| Gender | The gender of the participant or caregiver | Self-medication with antibiotics Storing antibiotics at home Taking antibiotics as prophylaxis Healthcare seeking behaviour Combined behaviour score |
13–15 19 20 28 35 45 48–51 |
| Education | The education level of the participant, his/her parent or the caregiver | Asking/pressuring doctors for antibiotics Self-medication with antibiotics Storing antibiotics at home Over-the-counter purchases Taking antibiotics as prophylaxis Healthcare seeking behaviour Combined behaviour score |
13 14 18–20 28 29 38 42 45 49–51 63 76 |
| Income | The household income or monthly allowance of the participant or caregiver | Self-medication with antibiotics Storing antibiotics at home Taking antibiotics as prophylaxis |
20 29 32 40 45 50 51 |
| Location | The rural/urban of residence of the participant or caregiver | Asking/pressuring doctors for antibiotics Self-medication with antibiotics Over-the-counter purchases Storing antibiotics at home Taking antibiotics as prophylaxis The likelihood to be prescribed with antibiotics by doctors Combined behaviour score |
13 18–20 24 29 43–45 47 49 50 |
| Region | Region of residence of the participant or caregiver—geographic area or economic development stage | Asking/pressuring doctors for antibiotics Self-medication with antibiotics Over-the-counter purchases Storing antibiotics at home Taking antibiotics as prophylaxis The likelihood to be prescribed with antibiotics by doctors |
13 20 28 50 51 |
| Policy | Health policy or AMR programme that might affect prescribing or access to antibiotics (eg, measures to de-incentivise over-prescription in public health facilities, including decoupling the link between facility income and the sale of medicines and policy that bans over-the-counter purchases) Financial incentives for antibiotic prescribing of doctors |
Self-medication with antibiotics Over-the-counter purchases* The likelihood to be prescribed with antibiotics by doctors |
23 24 28 |
| Norm | Participants’ view of how others treat illnesses and/or use antibiotics (non-China and non-predictor)* Healthcare providers reviewing others’ prescriptions (non-predictor)* |
The likelihood to be prescribed with antibiotics by doctors* | 59 75 77–79 |
| Point-of-care | Prescribing habits/capacity might vary at different levels of health facilities: tertiary hospital, secondary/county hospital, community health centres/township hospital or private clinics/village clinics | No evidence available to date | – |
*Non-predictor: effect is implied.
AMR, antimicrobial resistance; URTI, upper respiratory tract infections.