Skip to main content
. 2020 Oct 31;20(21):6219. doi: 10.3390/s20216219

Table 1.

Comparison between the proposed method and other research identifying solar panels using only thermal images with a complex background.

Method Description Weaknesses
Dhimish et al. [34] Identifies hot spots in an RGB image with a color ramp. Does not identify the affected solar panel.
The thermal images have only a panel in high resolution.
Libra et al. [35] Identifies hot spots in an RGB image with a color ramp. Does not identify the affected solar panel.
Does not segment the image
Liao et al. [31] Identifies hot spots in an RGB image with a color ramp.
Classic method based on filters for a binary classification of the image between faulty and non-faulty areas.
Does not identify the affected solar panel.
Assumes that in all the photo there are only panels
Lacks of methods to classify segments.
Alsafasfeh et al. [26] Segmentation based on hot pixels detection.
Classic method based on Canny edge detection
Does not identify the affected solar panel.
Lacks of methods to classify segments.
Addabbo et al. [32] Panel detection with classic methods based on template matching using normalized cross-correlation
Tested on large dataset
The thermal images present a few panels in high resolution.
It does not report or present solutions for the feautures 1, 4, and 5 of the complex background.
Alfaro-Mejía et al. [28] Classic method based on two techniques.
Performs an image transformation to orthogonize the detected panel
The thermal images present a few panels in high resolution.
It does not present solutions for any of the complex backgrounds
Uma et al. [33] Classic method with segmentation of the image using the k-means clustering algorithm. k-means is an unsupervised classification.
It does not present solutions for the feautures 3, 4, and 5 of the complex background.
Zhu et al. [30] learning with an algorithm based on a fully convolutional neural network and a dense conditional random field It does not propose a solution to identify panels that remained undetected by the deep learning method.
Greco et al. [29] Deep learning with a convolutional neural network framework called ’You only Look Once’ (YOLO)
Tested on large dataset
It does not propose a solution to identify panels that remained undetected by the deep learning method.