Table 1.
Method | Description | Drawbacks | Example Study |
---|---|---|---|
CVD | High temperature furnace up to 1000 °C, vacuum 1 Torr, catalyst, NH3 as nitrogen source, He as shielding gas | Complex instrumentation, very low yield | [27,28] |
Arc Discharge | Electric arc discharge conditions, pyridine and ammonia as a nitrogen carrier | Complex instrumentation, difficult to control, very low yield | [29] |
Pyrolysis | High temperature pyrolysis of a stolid mixture of GO—urea lattice, respectively | Limited yield, long time high temperature synthesis, application of GO instead of pure graphene | [30] |
Heat treating | Heating to 800–1000 °C a solid mixture of GO-nitrogen source, neutral atmosphere, melamine as a potential nitrogen source | [31] | |
Solvothermal | 200–300 °C, 4–5 h duration, dimethylformamide as a solvent and nitrogen source | Yield limited by the experimental vessel volume, use environmentally and health unfriendly reagents | [32] |
Gas Annealing | High temperature of 500–1000 °C during electrical annealing of GO in nitrogen atmosphere, ammonia gas (NH3) as a nitrogen source | GO applied instead of pure graphene/graphite, low yield, a high temperature method | [33,34] |
N2 Plasma Treatment | Nitrogen content controlled by the plasma strength and exposure time, example plasma generator parameters 40–200 W, 900 V DC bias, high vacuum 200 mTorr, 20–80 min treatment, graphene or GO as a key precursor, N2 and NH3 as nitrogen source |
Sophisticated instrumentation and challenging synthesis conditions, low yield | [35] |
Dry Ball Milling | Mechanochemical process, room temperature direct grinding of dry powdered graphite in the N2 or NH3 atmosphere, nitrogen content controllable by changing milling parameters | Unwanted insertion of impurities from the grinding setup, which must be removed by additional treatment, laboratory scale process | [36] |
Nanoscale High Energy Wet Ball Milling | Mechanochemical process, room to 80 °C wet milling; gas, liquid and solid nitrogen carriers permittable, GO advised as carbon precursor | Complex manufacturing pathway including frequent rising, laboratory scale process | [37] |