Table 1.
Monitoring Goal | Contact-Based Methods | Contactless Methods | Information Detail | Type of Recording | Main Measurement/Computing Challenge | Need for VT * |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1. Presence of breathing | XXX | XX | b-by-b | P/C | respiratory signal quality | - |
2. Adverse cardiac events | XXX | X | 60 s | C | wearable and unobtrusive systems | - |
3. Apnea | XXX | X | raw data | C | hypopnea detection | ●●● |
4. Pneumonia | XXX | XX | 60 s | P/C | solutions for low-income countries | - |
5. Clinical deterioration | XXX | XX | 60 s | P/C | acceptance of technologies | - |
6. Dyspnea | XXX | X | b-by-b | C | motion artifacts | ●● |
7. Pain | XXX | X | b-by-b/60s | C | detection of respiratory depression | ●● |
8. Emotional stress | XXX | XX | b-by-b | P/C | processing of video images | ● |
9. Cognitive load | XXX | XX | b-by-b/60 s | C | accurate and unobtrusive systems | - |
10. Environment-induced stress | XXX | X | 60 s | C | change of sensor properties | ● |
11. Physical effort | XXX | X | b-by-b/5 s | C | motion artifacts | - |
12. Respiratory artifacts | XX | XXX | raw data | P | respiratory features in real-time | ●●● |
13. Respiratory biofeedback | XXX | XX | raw data | P | respiratory features in real-time | ●● |
X, can be used in some instances; XX, suitable; XXX, advised solution; b-by-b, breath-by-breath; P, periodic monitoring; C, continuous monitoring; VT, tidal volume; *, or respiratory amplitude as a surrogate for tidal volume; -, not necessarily needed; ●, useful; ●●, very useful; ●●●, required.