Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2022 Jan 1.
Published in final edited form as: Biosens Bioelectron. 2020 Oct 9;171:112687. doi: 10.1016/j.bios.2020.112687

Table 1.

Various Types of 3D MEAs for in vitro and in vivo applications

Type of 3D MEA Fabrication Method Materials Geometry / Layout / Features Ref
In vitro Cardiac
  • Photolithography

  • Ion beam etching

  • Multilayered Ti–Pt–Ti–Au–Ti–SiO 2-coated glass substrate

  • 2 μm-wide in diameter of nanoring

  • 10- to 20-nm-thick Au nanoring

  • Multilayered wall of the nanovolcano

(Desbiol les et al., 2019)
  • Photolithography

  • TiN, Au, SU-8

  • Free standing/ flexible/ mesh

  • 32 electrodes (50 × 50 μm2)

  • Recording/stimulating with same electrodes

  • Folded device

(Feiner et al. 2016)
  • 3D printing

  • Carbon black, TPU

  • Cantilever geometry

  • Stretching a soft strain gauge embedded in the cantilever

(Lind et al., 2017)
Neural
  • Photolithography/

  • Wet / dry etching

  • Ti / Au / Ti on polyimide

  • 20 nm Ti / 250 nm Au / 20 nm Ti in thickness

  • 50 μm diameter individual electrodes

  • Flexible polyimide probes of length 1100 μm and width 90 μm contain eight 50 μm diameter individual electrodes

  • Probe would bend during actuation

(Soscia et al., 2020)
  • Photolithography/

  • E-beam lithography

  • Ti / Ni / Ti / Ni

  • 30 / 200 / 50 / 200 nm

  • (adhesion/conduction/diffusionbarrier/silicidation)

  • Nanowire geometries

  • Independent electrical addressability

(Liu et al., 2017)
  • Photolithography

  • Wet / dry etching

  • E-beam lithography

  • Electrodeposition

  • PtB, Ti, Pt,

  • 20 nm Ti, 200 nm Pt

  • PtB deposition on the Pt electrodes

  • 4,096 platinum-black nanowire electrodes array

(Abbott et al., 2020)
In vivo Heart
  • Photopatteming

  • PVA-coated Au gel electrodes on polyrotaxane matrix

  • 12 × 12 transistors

  • Polymer thickness: 1.4 mm

  • 3D wrinkles for strain absorption (> 100 %)

  • Adhesive to biological surfaces

(Lee et al., 2014)
  • Micromachining/

  • Photoetching

  • Au microneedles

  • Thin PDMS membrane

  • Barb width: 790 – 1170 mm

  • Shaft width: 230 – 480 mm

  • Height: ~ 1.5 mm

  • Microneedles with 3D arrowhead shapes

  • Stretchability up to ~ 63% strain

(Guvana sen et al., 2017)
  • Galvanic-free epitaxial deposition

  • Ag–Au core–sheath

  • nanowire composite mesh

  • Nanowire diameter: 140 nm Nanowire thickness: 35 nm

  • Highly stretchable (> 800 % strain)

  • Electrically stable to strains (> 100%)

(Choi et al., 2018)
Brain
  • Photolithography

  • Electroplating

  • Pt-coated Au-TiO2 nanowires

  • Electrode count: 32

  • Electrode size: ~ 3000 mm2

  • Highly soft and stretchable to enable craniotomies smaller than the probe's size

(Tybran dt et al. 2018)
  • Vapor deposition

  • Electroplating

  • Cr/Au electrode; PEDOT:PSS/Pt-black wrinkles

  • Wrinkle wavelength

  • 11.2 - 35.7 mm

  • Enhanced interfacial surface area

  • Stable ECoG recording and optical stimulation

(Ji et al., 2019)
  • Photolithography

  • SU-8 insulation

  • Pt/Au electrodes

  • 30 mm × 30 mm/

  • 10 mm × 20 mm

  • Ultraflexibility to conform with brain tissue

  • Stable performances in mice for extended time

(Luan et al., 2017)
  • Electron-beam lithography

  • Au electrodes

  • SU-8 insulation

  • Au electrode: 100 nm

  • Total thickness: ~ 1 mm

  • Careful handling for stable chronical recording and nondegrading tissue–probe interface

(Wei et al., 2018)
  • Photolithography

  • Pt electrode

  • Au interconnect

  • Top/bottom SU-8 layers

  • Width: 2 mm

  • Electrode Diameter: 10-20 mm

  • Unit cell: 333 × 125 mm

  • Match the subcellular feature sizes and mechanical properties of neurons

(Yang et al., 2019)