TABLE 5.
Comparison of amino acids in the C4 PEP carboxylases of the Allionia and Okenia/Boerhavia C4 clades with PEP carboxylase sites under positive selection in C4 grasses.
| Sites with posterior probability > 0.999 |
Prob > 0.99 |
Prob > 0.95 |
|||||||||||||||||
| Clade | 466 | 517 | 531 | 560 | 577 | 579 | 625 | 637 | 761 | 780 | 794 | 807 | 572 | 599 | 813 | 665 | 733 | 863 | 866 |
| Boerhavia/Okenia | Met | Thr | Ala | Arg | Ser | Ala | Leu | Met | Ala | Ala | Phe | Lys | Gln | Ile | Arg, Gln* | His | Met | Lys | Glu |
| Allionia | Met | Thr | Ala | Arg | Ser | Ala | Val | Met | Ala | Ala | Phe | Lys | Gln | Ile | Gln | His | Phe | Asn | Glu |
| C3 Nyctag | Met | Thr | Ala | Arg | Ser | Ala | Val | Met | Ser | Ala | Phe | Arg | Glu | Ile | Arg | His | Phe | Asn | Glu |
| C4 grasses (Christin et al. (2007) | Ile, Val | Ala, Cys | Pro | Pro | Ser | Glu | Ala | Leu, Phe | Ala | Ser | Val | Lys | Gln | Val | Gln | Asn | Met, Val | Lys | Glu |
Site numbers correspond to the maize PEP carboxylase gene (PEPC). Sites under positive selection were identified by a screen of grass lineages examined by Christin et al. (2007). Posterior probabilities noted with blue headers are from that study. Sites showing an identical amino acid substitution in either or both C4 Nyctaginaceae lineages are highlighted in yellow. We list the most frequent positively selected amino acid(s) at each site in C4 grasses. The species in the C3 Nyctag clade are the North American Xerophytic C3 species in the PEPC1 gene tree in Supplementary Figure 2, which exhibited identical amino acids at the sites shown. *Gln is only present in B. burbidgeana; the other Boerhavia and Okenia have Arg at position 813.