Skip to main content
. 2020 Nov 2;10:519073. doi: 10.3389/fonc.2020.519073

Table 1.

Characteristics of the included studies.

First author Publish year Region Study type Number of patients EGFR mutation Female (%) Age(years) Smoker(%) Adenocarcinoma (%) Stage Lymph node metastasis (%) Brain metastasis (%) EGFR mutation detection methods Scores Of AHRQ
Xuanwei Non-Xuanwei Total Yes No Rate
Guo et al. (27) 2019 China, Xuanwei Retro 85 NA 85 39 46 45.88% 41.18% 54 (36-78) NG 80.00% NG NG NG Targeted NGS 10
Zhou et al. (28) 2018 China, Yunnan Retro 20 192 212 64 148 30.19% 38.21% 57.1 (31-86) 44.81% 81.60% I, II, III, IV NG 18.87% Super ARMS-PCR and dd PCR 11
Zhou et al. (21) 2017 China, Yunnan Retro 63 384 447 156 291 34.90% 44.97% <65 (69.4%); 65-75 (23.5%); >75 (7.2%) 47.43% 86.58% I, II, III, IV NG 14.32% ARMS-PCR 11
Chen et al. (13) 2016 China, Yunnan Retro 90 168 258 124 134 48.06% 52.33% <=60 (68.6%); >60 (31.4%) 27.13% 87.60% I, II, III, IV 29.07% NG ARMS-PCR 10
Yang et al. (22) 2016 China, Yunnan Retro 81 169 250 131 119 52.40% NG NG NG NG NG NG NG ARMS-Taqman 10
Yang et al. (26) 2016 China, Xuanwei Retro 63 NA 63 35 28 55.56% 42.86% <50 (54.0%); >=50 (46.0%) 39.68% 84.13% NG 17.46% NG ARMS-Taqman 10
Hosgood et al. (14) 2013 China, Xuanwei Retro 40 NA 40 14 26 35.00% NG 46.5 ± 10 0 80.00% NG NG NG SNaPshot and separate PCR-based sizing technique 10

Retro, Retrospective study; EGFR, Epidermal growth factor receptor; NA, Not Available; NG, Not given; AHRQ, Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality; NGS, Next generation sequencing; ARMS, super amplification refractory mutation system; PCR, polymerase chain reaction; dd PCR, Droplet Digital polymerase chain reaction; GS, gene sequencing.