Skip to main content
. 2020 Nov 13;8:e10311. doi: 10.7717/peerj.10311

Table 4. Photochemical quenching coefficient and non-photochemical quenching coefficient of noodle rice as influenced by different biochar levels under low and high N rates.

Treatment/season Tillering Heading Maturity
qP NPQ qP NPQ qP NPQ
S1
N1C 0.33de 0.82a 0.29c 0.75a 0.21e 0.77a
N2C 0.41cde 0.66ab 0.45abc 0.64ab 0.32cde 0.40bc
N1B1 0.34de 0.81a 0.32bc 0.78a 0.28de 0.86a
N1B2 0.47bcd 0.43cd 0.43abc 0.43cd 0.54a 0.30c
N1B3 0.69a 0.28d 0.56ab 0.28d 0.38bcd 0.42bc
N2B1 0.54ab 0.51bc 0.32bc 0.50bc 0.44abc 0.65ab
N2B2 0.61ab 0.38cd 0.61a 0.38cd 0.57a 0.42bc
N2B3 0.67a 0.41cd 0.57a 0.41 0.49ab 0.53abc
S2
N1C 0.25f 0.65ab 0.25e 0.74a 0.27cd 0.70a
N2C 0.40de 0.61ab 0.39cd 0.63ab 0.40cd 0.61ab
N1B1 0.35ef 0.79a 0.32de 0.77a 0.38 0.47abc
N1B2 0.61ab 0.30c 0.45cd 0.42cd 0.46bc 0.41bc
N1B3 0.53bcd 0.42bc 0.63a 0.28d 0.21d 0.28c
N2B1 0.46cde 0.60ab 0.51abc 0.49bc 0.46bc 0.60ab
N2B2 0.58abc 0.48bc 0.57ab 0.38cd 0.58ab 0.48ab
N2B3 0.70a 0.29c 0.63a 0.40cd 0.70a 0.29c
Tillering Heading Maturity
SOV qP NPQ qP NPQ qP NPQ
Biochar (B) ** ** ns ns ** **
Nitrogen(N) * ns ns ns * *
Season(S) ns ns ns ns ns ns
BxN * * ** ** * *
BxS ns ns ns ns ns ns
NxS ns ns ns ns ns ns
BxNxS ns ns ns ns ns ns

Notes.

qP
photochemical quenching coefficient
qNP
Non-photochemical quenching coefficient (qN)

N1C–N; lower dose + Control (no biochar), N 2C–N; higher dose + Control (no biochar), N 1B1–N; lower dose + Biochar 20 t ha −1, N1B2–N; lower dose + Biochar 40 t ha−1, N1B3–N; lower dose + Biochar 60 t ha−1, N2B 1–N; higher dose + Biochar 20 t ha−1, N2B2–N; higher dose + biochar 40 t ha −1, N2B3–N; higher dose + Biochar 60 t ha−1. Values followed by the same letters, within column, are not significantly different at P ≤ 0.05. SOV-source of variation, ** indicate the significant difference P ≤ 0.01 and * indicate P = 0.01 − 0.05.