Table 1.
Data generation models for simulations under each scenario.
| Scenario | Data generating model and scenario description | Impact on outcome | Index |
|---|---|---|---|
| Standard | log(µij) = α + θ × Xij + bi Description: No confounding, early adoption, or effect modification |
None. | 1 |
| Confounding | log(µij) = α + θ × Xij + βij + bi Description: At each time period j, clusters randomly exposed to event inducing confounding for remainder of study period; , where is total number of clusters unexposed to event prior to time period j. |
βij ∼ unif [−1, 0] if cluster i exposed during time period j; 0 otherwise. | 2.1 |
| βij ∼ unif [0, 1] if cluster i exposed during time period j; 0 otherwise. | 2.2 | ||
| Early adoption |
Description: At each time period j, control clusters prematurely adopt intervention components; , where is the number of control clusters not receiving the intervention prior to time period j. |
θij ∼ unif [θ, 0] if control cluster i prematurely adopts intervention at time period j; 0 otherwise. | 3 |
| Confounding + Early adoption (or Effect modification) |
Description: At each time period j, clusters are randomly exposed to confounding events and control clusters prematurely adopt intervention components, where and are defined above. Control clusters may be exposed to both confounding factors and early adoption. Data generation model for effect modification is similar. |
βij ∼ unif [−1, 0] if cluster i exposed to confounding event during time period j; 0 otherwise. θij is defined as above. | 4.1 |
| βij ∼ unif [0, 1] if cluster i exposed to confounding event during time period j; 0 otherwise. θij is defined as above. | 4.2 |
Data is simulated under 4 general scenarios. The data generating model for each simulation scenario is displayed in the second column. Here µij is the expected rate of opioid overdose deaths in cluster i during time period j, θ is the intervention effect and is set to log(0.6), and Xij is an indicator of whether cluster i is scheduled to receive intervention during time period j and is based on the SWD represented by Figure 1. The fixed intercept α is set to −10 and the random intercept bi is simulated from a N (0, 0.30) distribution. A description of the selection process for exposure to confounding events or early adoption is provided in the second column (below the data generating model). The impact of confounding factors and/or early adoption on the outcome is detailed in the third column. In scenarios 2 and 4, we allow confounding factors to have either a positive impact on the outcome (scenarios 2.1 and 4.1) or a negative impact on the outcome (scenarios 2.2 and 4.2).