Change in ASES score for each treatment strategy compared to MCID threshold for either nonoperative or operative intervention. Sample size is directly proportional to the size of the circle. The red “x” denotes the weighted average change in CMS for all treatment strategies, which is influenced by sample size. PT, Physical therapy; D, Débridement; PR, Partial repair; GI, Graft interposition; TTA, Arthroscopic tendon transfer; TTO, Open tendon transfer; SCR-HDA, Superior capsular reconstruction—human dermal allograft; SCR-TFL, Superior capsular reconstruction—tensor fascia lata autograft; BA, Balloon arthroplasty; RSA, Reverse shoulder arthroplasty; MCID, Minimum clinically important difference.