Table 1.
Considerations | Definition | Formula | Implications in EC | Ideal EC diagnostic test criteria |
---|---|---|---|---|
Sensitivity | Probability that a person with a disease will test positive |
TP
TP + FN |
A low sensitivity would mean a large proportion of women with EC will be falsely re-assured leading to delayed presentation (the false negatives who will later present at an advanced stage) and poor survival. | Maximal sensitivity (100%) |
Specificity | Probability that a person without a disease will test negative |
TN
TN + FP |
A low specificity would mean a large proportion of women without EC will undergo further unnecessary & invasive tests/treatments. The worried well population also increases. | Maximal specificity (100%) |
Positive predictive value
(PPV) |
Probability that a positive test will correctly identify those with the disease |
TP
TP + FP |
A low PPV has implications for women with a positive test, a large proportion of whom will undergo further unnecessary diagnostic tests or even treatments that are not indicated. | Maximal PPV (100%) |
Negative predictive value
(NPV) |
Probability that a negative test will correctly identify those without the disease |
TN
TN + FN |
A low NPV has implications for women with a negative test, a large proportion of whom will be falsely reassured. | Maximal NPV (100%) |
Clinical Utility | Risks and benefits resulting from test use. | Rates of acceptability, complications and side effects | A highly invasive test is less acceptable to patients and may lead to complications. | Safe, minimally invasive, sensitive and specific, acceptable, minimal side effects |
Cost Effectiveness | Direct monetary costs and indirect costs associated with the disease, tests and a misdiagnosis of the disease | Cost Effectiveness Ratio CER: Cost of intervention Effect of intervention |
An expensive test is unlikely to be affordable by patients or health service providers including the NHS | Cheap/cost effective |
TP, True Positives; TN, True Negatives; FP, False Positives; FN, False Negatives.