Table A3:
Author, Year N (TAVI/SAVR) | Baseline | 30 Days | 1 Year |
---|---|---|---|
Mack et al, 201918 950 (496/454) PARTNER 3 |
N = 950 (496 TAVI/454 SAVR) NYHA I, n (%) TAVI: 2 (0.4) SAVR: 7 (1.5) NYHA II, n (%) TAVI: 339 (68.3) SAVR: 339 (74.7) NYHA III, n (%) TAVI: 152 (30.6) SAVR: 103 (22.7) NYHA IV, n (%) TAVI: 3 (0.6) SAVR: 5 (1.1) |
N = 926 (493 TAVI/433 SAVR) NYHA I, n (%) TAVI: 396 (80.3) SAVR: 289 (66.7) RD, % (95% CI) −13.4 (−19.2 to −7.9) NYHA II, n (%) TAVI: 339 (68.3) SAVR: 339 (74.7) NYHA III, n (%) TAVI: 91 (18.5) SAVR: 125 (28.9) NYHA IV, n (%) TAVI: 6 (1.2) SAVR: 19 (44) |
N = 887 (480 TAVI/407 SAVR) NYHA I, n (%) TAVI: 395 (82.3) SAVR: 339 (83.3) RD, % (95% CI) 1.0 (−4.0 to 6.0) NYHA II, n (%) TAVI: 339 (16.7) SAVR: 339 (74.7) NYHA III, n (%) TAVI: 80 (16.7) SAVR: 62 (15.2) NYHA IV, n (%) TAVI: 5 (1.0) SAVR: 6 (1.5) |
Popma et al, 2019 1,403 (725/678) Evolut LRT |
N = 1,403 (725 TAVI/678 SAVR) NYHA I, n (%) AVI: 76 (10.5) SAVR: 63 (9.3) NYHA II, n (%) TAVI: 467 (64.4) SAVR: 422 (62.2) NYHA III, n (%) TAVI: 181 (25.0) SAVR: 190 (28.0) NYHA IV, n (%) TAVI: 1 (0.1) SAVR: 3 (0.4) |
N = 1,331 (706 TAVI/625 SAVR) NYHA I, n (%) TAVI: 545 (77.2) SAVR: 416 (66.6) NYHA II, n (%) TAVI: 149 (21.1) SAVR: 179 (28.6) NYHA III, n (%) TAVI: 12 (1.7) SAVR: 29 (4.6) NYHA IV, n (%) TAVI: 0 SAVR: 1 (0.2) |
N = 770 (428 TAVI/342 SAVR) Mean change from baseline (SD) TAVI: 0.9 (0.7) SAVR: 1.0 (0.7) Mean difference (95% BCrI) −0.1 (−0.2 to 0.0) NYHA I, n (%) TAVI: 336 (78.5) SAVR: 279 (81.6) NYHA II, n (%) TAVI: 84 (19.6) SAVR: 59 (17.3) NYHA III, n (%) TAVI: 7 (1.6) SAVR: 4 (1.2) NYHA IV, n (%) TAVI: 1 (0.2) SAVR: 0 |
Abbreviations: BCrI, Bayesian credible interval; NYHA, New York Heart Association; RD, risk difference; SAVR, surgical aortic valve replacement; SD, standard deviation; TAVI, transcatheter aortic valve implantation.