TABLE 2.
The main outcomes, limitations and future perspectives of the hiPSCs-derived organoids models of kidney diseases are described.
Kidney organoid models of disease | |||
Model-disease type and references | Outcomes | Limitations and challenges | Future perspectives |
Mucin 1 kidney disease (MKD) Dvela-Levitt et al., 2019 | Human iPSC-derived organoids from MKD patients exhibited Muc1 protein mislocalization in tubular cells. Organoid cells responded to the drug BRD90 in a similar manner as in mouse models and patients with MKD. | No functional assays, such as tubular absorption, were carried out in MKD organoids. | Developing semi-automated culture systems and analysis approaches can make this system a valuable drug testing tool for MKD. |
Polycystic kidney disease (PKD) Freedman et al., 2015; Cruz et al., 2017; Czerniecki et al., 2018; Low et al., 2019 | These human organoids from PKD1/PKD2 KO hiPSCs extensively formed cysts in vitro and can be adapted to high-throughput screening. Using this culture format, a potential involvement of non-muscle myosin in cystogenesis was identified. | PKD patient-derived hiPSCs did not sufficiently form cysts, hampering the application of this organoid system to study the genotypes of patients. | Optimizing culture conditions to induce cysts in patient-derived organoids will provide a highly useful assay for studying disease pathogenesis and developing personalized therapeutic strategies. |
ITF40 Nephronophthisis ciliopathic renal disease Forbes et al., 2018 | Somatic cells from a patient with compound heterozygous mutations in IFT140 were reprogrammed and corrected with CRISPR/Cas9. Primary cilia and apico-basal defects were observed in tubular cells of patient-derived kidney organoids but not in gene-corrected isogenic controls. | Primary cilia and spheroid polarity defects were not present in all organoids, which limits the potential use of the system in drug screening applications. | Generation of iPSC-derived organoids from patients with different mutations in NPHP genes will help to elucidate the mechanisms of Nephronophthisis pathogenesis and explain the differences between the clinical phenotypes. |
Podocalyxin deficiency Kim et al., 2017 | Knockout of podocalyxin demonstrated its importance for microvilli formation and podocyte spacing. Podocalyxin-KO organoids phenocopied, to some degree, the pathological features of the kidney in podocalyxin knockout mice, validating the use of organoids for understanding human podocyte development. | Podocalyxin deficiency is not compatible with life, and newborns with such defects are rarely reported. Therefore, although podocalyxin-deficient organoids can be used to study the role of podocalyxin in early steps of organogenesis, are less useful for studies in adult human diseases. | A mutation variant of unknown significance in PODXL has been identified in humans, the generation of patient-specific hiPSCs and their differentiation could be a valuable tool to investigate the pathogenesis of PODXL mutations in humans. |