Skip to main content
. 2020 Nov 21;7(1):14–26. doi: 10.1016/j.cdtm.2020.11.002

Table 1.

Key papers for ME/CFS patient studies.

Activity Reference Finding Therapeutic Investigated Cell Type/Tissue Investigated
Mitochondrial metabolic pathways Fluge et al 2016100 Impaired pyruvate dehydrogenase, consistent with inadequate ATP production, excessive lactate on exertion NA PBMCs
Metabolic response to exercise Brown et al 2015101 Impaired AMP kinase activation, glucose uptake NA Skeletal muscle cells
Cellular metabolism Naviaux et al 201623 Reduced metabolites in 20 biochemical pathways consistent with hypometabolic syndrome NA Plasma
Mitochondrial metabolism Comhaire et al 201852 Reduction in fatigue severity consistent with existing mitochondrial hypometabolism and impaired pyruvate dehydrogenase Sodium Dichloroacetate (Oral administration) NA
Mitochondrial metabolism Forsyth et al 199953 31% of patients had a positive reaction to NADH NADH (Oral administration ENADA) NA
Cellular energy synthesis Teitelbaum et al 200650 Improvement in energy, sleep, mental clarity, pain intensity and well-being d-ribose (Oral administration) NA
Cellular stress, Inflammation Sweetman et al 2019102 Transcriptome -changes in stress, inflammation pathways, metabolic regulation, mitochondrial function, and circadian clock. NA PBMCs
Metabolic, Immune and Neurological Helliwell et al 2020103 Changes in DNA methylation indicate abnormal immune, neurological and metabolic functions NA PBMCs
Oxidative stress Jammes et al 2005104 Incremental exercise resulted in oxidative stress with alterations in muscle membrane NA Blood samples
Mitochondrial stress Tomas et al 201721 Lower maximal respiration indicating inability to compensate for stress NA PBMCs
Mitochondrial ATP production Lawson et al 201634 Increased cristae density in patients. Increased ATP from non-mitochondrial sources NA PBMCs
Mitochondrial ATP production Missailidis et al 202022 Complex V inefficiency in ATP production NA Immortalised lymphocytes
Mitochondrial complex activity Tomas et al 201932 No observed differences in mitochondrial complex activity NA PBMCs, skeletal muscle cells
Mitochondrial Complexes, ATP production and oxidative stress Sweetman et al 20208 Disturbances in proteins of (a) mitochondrial complexes I & V, (b) regulating reactive oxygen species, and in mitochondrial pathways NA PBMCs
CoQ10 Maes et al 200976 Deficiency in CoQ10 in patient group correlating with symptom severity CoQ10 Plasma
CoQ10 Castro-Marrero et al 201548 Improvement in fatigue levels and biochemical parameters (NAD+, CoQ10, ATP, citrate synthase and lipoperoxides) CoQ10 (Oral supplementation)
CoQ10/MitoQ Wood 202078 An association of CoQ10 levels with mitochondrial function, enhanced by supplementation of cells with exogenous C0Q10. Supplementation of MitoQ orally improved bioenergetic profiles of a subject. CoQ10
MitoQ (oral supplementation)
PBMCs,
MitoQ Kelso et al 200187 MitoQ protects mitochondria from hydrogen peroxide-induced apoptosis MitoQ Human osteosarcoma cells
MitoQ James et al 200579 MitoQ10 was an effective antioxidant against lipid peroxidation, peroxynitrite and superoxide. MitoQ Rat heart mitochondria

Non-patient studies showing MitoQ is a powerful antioxidant in mitochondria. PBMC: Peripheral blood mononuclear cell; NA: Not applicable; NADH: Reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide; CoQ10: Coenzyme Q10.