Table 1.
Key papers for ME/CFS patient studies.
| Activity | Reference | Finding | Therapeutic Investigated | Cell Type/Tissue Investigated |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mitochondrial metabolic pathways | Fluge et al 2016100 | Impaired pyruvate dehydrogenase, consistent with inadequate ATP production, excessive lactate on exertion | NA | PBMCs |
| Metabolic response to exercise | Brown et al 2015101 | Impaired AMP kinase activation, glucose uptake | NA | Skeletal muscle cells |
| Cellular metabolism | Naviaux et al 201623 | Reduced metabolites in 20 biochemical pathways consistent with hypometabolic syndrome | NA | Plasma |
| Mitochondrial metabolism | Comhaire et al 201852 | Reduction in fatigue severity consistent with existing mitochondrial hypometabolism and impaired pyruvate dehydrogenase | Sodium Dichloroacetate (Oral administration) | NA |
| Mitochondrial metabolism | Forsyth et al 199953 | 31% of patients had a positive reaction to NADH | NADH (Oral administration ENADA) | NA |
| Cellular energy synthesis | Teitelbaum et al 200650 | Improvement in energy, sleep, mental clarity, pain intensity and well-being | d-ribose (Oral administration) | NA |
| Cellular stress, Inflammation | Sweetman et al 2019102 | Transcriptome -changes in stress, inflammation pathways, metabolic regulation, mitochondrial function, and circadian clock. | NA | PBMCs |
| Metabolic, Immune and Neurological | Helliwell et al 2020103 | Changes in DNA methylation indicate abnormal immune, neurological and metabolic functions | NA | PBMCs |
| Oxidative stress | Jammes et al 2005104 | Incremental exercise resulted in oxidative stress with alterations in muscle membrane | NA | Blood samples |
| Mitochondrial stress | Tomas et al 201721 | Lower maximal respiration indicating inability to compensate for stress | NA | PBMCs |
| Mitochondrial ATP production | Lawson et al 201634 | Increased cristae density in patients. Increased ATP from non-mitochondrial sources | NA | PBMCs |
| Mitochondrial ATP production | Missailidis et al 202022 | Complex V inefficiency in ATP production | NA | Immortalised lymphocytes |
| Mitochondrial complex activity | Tomas et al 201932 | No observed differences in mitochondrial complex activity | NA | PBMCs, skeletal muscle cells |
| Mitochondrial Complexes, ATP production and oxidative stress | Sweetman et al 20208 | Disturbances in proteins of (a) mitochondrial complexes I & V, (b) regulating reactive oxygen species, and in mitochondrial pathways | NA | PBMCs |
| CoQ10 | Maes et al 200976 | Deficiency in CoQ10 in patient group correlating with symptom severity | CoQ10 | Plasma |
| CoQ10 | Castro-Marrero et al 201548 | Improvement in fatigue levels and biochemical parameters (NAD+, CoQ10, ATP, citrate synthase and lipoperoxides) | CoQ10 (Oral supplementation) | |
| CoQ10/MitoQ | Wood 202078 | An association of CoQ10 levels with mitochondrial function, enhanced by supplementation of cells with exogenous C0Q10. Supplementation of MitoQ orally improved bioenergetic profiles of a subject. | CoQ10 MitoQ (oral supplementation) |
PBMCs, |
| ∗MitoQ | Kelso et al 200187 | MitoQ protects mitochondria from hydrogen peroxide-induced apoptosis | MitoQ | Human osteosarcoma cells |
| ∗MitoQ | James et al 200579 | MitoQ10 was an effective antioxidant against lipid peroxidation, peroxynitrite and superoxide. | MitoQ | Rat heart mitochondria |
Non-patient studies showing MitoQ is a powerful antioxidant in mitochondria. PBMC: Peripheral blood mononuclear cell; NA: Not applicable; NADH: Reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide; CoQ10: Coenzyme Q10.