Table 3.
Author, Year | Follow-up Time | Total No. of Pts. | All stages Included | No. of patients with T2 larynx cancer | Treatment modality | LC rates, % | LC rates with laryngeal preservation, % | uLC rates, % | OS rates, % | Cause-specific survival rates, % |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Fletcher et al., 1980 27 | NR | 507 | T2 | 175 | RT | 74 | ||||
Harwood et al., 1981 28 | NR | 244 | T2 | 244 | RT | 69 (5-y) | ||||
Wang, 1997 29 | NR | 902 | T1-T2 | T2a 145 T2b 92 |
RT | 77 (5-y) 71 (5-y) |
92 (5-y) 84 (5-y) |
|||
Le et al., 1997 30 | Median 9.7 y | 398 | T1-T2 | 83 | RT | 70 (5-y) | uLRC 91 (5-y) | 63 (10-y) | 91 (10-y) | |
Warde et al 1998 31 | Median 6.8 y | 735 | T1-T2 | 286 | RT | 69 (5-y) | ||||
Garden et al., 2003 32 | Median 6.8 y | 230 | T2 | 230 | RT | 72 (5-y) | 73 (5-y) | 92 (5-y) | ||
Short et al., 2006 33 | Median 4.9 y | 145 | T1-T2 | 43 | RT | 80 (5-y LRC) | ||||
Taguchi et al., 2006 34 | Median 32 mo | 20 | T2 | 20 | CCRT | 95 (3-y) | 100 (3-y) | 100 (3-y) | ||
Hafidh et al., 2009 35 | Mean 37 mo | 373 | T1-T4 | 38 | RT | 63.3 (5-y) | ||||
Chera et al., 2010 7 | Median 12 y | 585 | T1-T2 | T2a 165** T2b 95 |
RT | T2a: 80 (5-y) T2b: 70 (5-y) |
T2a 81 (5-y) T2b 74 (5-y) |
T2a 76 (5-y) T2b 78 (5-y) |
T2a 94 (5-y) T2b 90 (5-y) |
|
Kim et al., 2012 12 | Median 7.1 y | 157 | T1-T2 | 32 | RT | 62 (5-y) | ||||
Furusaka et al., 2012 36 | Median 9.4 y | 57 | T2 | 57 | RT | 60.4 (5-yr) 50.1 (10-yr) |
88.5 (5-y) 73.5 (10-y) |
|||
Ermis et al., 2015 37 | Median 72 mo | 132 | T1-T2 | 64 | RT | 80.9 (5-y) | 95.8 (5-y) |
Abbreviations: NR, not reported; y, year(s); mo, month(s); RT, radiation therapy; CCRT, concurrent chemoradiation; LC, local control; LRC: loco-regional control; uLC, ultimate local control; uLRC, ultimate loco-regional control
T2a and T2b classifications were based on the 2nd edition of the American Joint Committee on Cancer (AJCC) staging system. T2 is not subdivided into T2a and T2b in the 8th edition of the AJCC staging system.