TABLE 3.
Papers (N)/definitions (n) | PPD (mm) | CAL (mm) | BOP (%) | Other | Reference |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
N = 38/ n = 39 | n = 35 | n = 24 | n = 16 | ||
1 | <3 | Beklen et al, 2014 67 | |||
2 | <3 | Özcan et al, 2015 76 | |||
3 | <3 | Duran‐Pinedo et al, 2014 69 | |||
4 | <3.5 | Jones et al, 2013 35 | |||
5 | <3.5 | Schjetlein et al, 2014 14 | |||
6 | <4 | Garneata et al, 2015 16 | |||
7 | <4 | Gursoy et al, 2013 52 | |||
8 | <4 | No clinical sign + no X‐ray bone loss | Ramírez et al, 2014 66 | ||
9 | <5 | Prodan et al, 2016 79 | |||
10 | <3 | Kirst et al, 2015 77 | |||
11 | <3 | Kim et al, 2013 58 | |||
12 | <3 | Graziani et al, 2018 36 | |||
13 | No X‐ray bone loss | Rathnayake et al, 2013 50 | |||
14 | =0 | =0 | No clinical sign + no X‐ray bone loss | Huang et al, 2018 63 | |
15 | <3 | <3 | Wang et al, 2013 51 | ||
16 | <3 | =0 | Guentsch et al, 2014 40 | ||
17 | <3 | =0 | Tabari et al, 2014 70 | ||
18 | <3 | =0 | Pushparani et al, 2014 60 | ||
19 | <3 | =0 | GI = 0 + PI = 0 | Ghallab et al, 2015 72 | |
20 | <3 | =0 | GI = 0 + PI = 0 | Hassan et al, 2015 41 | |
21 | <3 | <2 | Mesa et al, 2014 65 | ||
22 | <3 | <3 | Zimmermann et al, 2013 47 | ||
23 | <4 | <4 | Kebschull et al, 2013 53 | ||
24 | <3 | <10 | Tabari et al, 2013 70 | ||
25 | <3 | <10 | Apatzidou et al, 2013 48 | ||
26 | <3 | <30 | Salazar et al, 2013 54 | ||
27 | <4 | <15 | Muthu et al, 2015 44 | ||
28 | <4 | <10 | Raber‐Durlacher et al, 2013 45 | ||
29 | <3 | =0 | =0 | Kurşunlu et al, 2015 74 | |
30 | <3 | <3 | =0 | Mourão et al, 2013 34 | |
31 | <3 | =0 | =0 | No clinical sign + no history | Lavu et al, 2015 73 |
32 | <3 | =0 | <10 | Singh et al, 2014 68 | |
33 | <3 | <1 | <10 | Sukhtankar et al, 2013 37 | |
34 | <3 | <2 | <20 | No X‐ray bone loss | Sağlam et al, 2017 82 |
35 a | <3 | <3 | <10 | Lourenço et al, 2014 18 | |
<4 | <4 | <5 | Lourenço et al, 2014 18 | ||
36 | <3 | <3 | <10 | No X‐ray bone loss | Leite et al, 2014 42 |
37 | <3 | ≤3 | <20 | Papathanasiou et al, 2014 64 | |
38 | <4 | <2 | <10 | Ebersole et al, 2013 49 |
Abbreviations: BOP, bleeding on probing; CAL, clinical attachment level; PDD, probing pocket depth.
Lourenço et al provided two sets of periodontally healthy definition in one paper. 'Gray shades' means a single criterion or combination involving PPD/CAL/BOP to define periodontal health.