Skip to main content
. 2020 Nov 12;11:585765. doi: 10.3389/fphys.2020.585765

Table 2.

Summary of the effects of exercise training on asymmetry and symmetry outcomes, method of calculation, and the results of the 9 articles reviewed, grouped by training modality as resistance, aerobic, and combined exercise.

References Asymmetry and symmetry outcomes Calculation Δ Asymmetry and symmetry outcomes (EX 1, EX2, Con)
Resistance exercise (n = 5)
Liu et al., 2016 Dynamic WB* Non-paretic side/paretic side 1.70, NA, 0.06
Sheikh et al., 2016 Static WB
Swing time
Stance time
Step length
Gait symmetry ratio
% of total body weight supported by paretic limb
Larger swing time/smaller swing time
Larger stance time/smaller stance time
Larger step length/smaller step length
[(Paretic swing time/paretic stance time)]/[(non-paretic swing time/non-paretic stance time)]
9.86, NA, 2.43
0.32, NA, 0.20
0.03, NA, −0.03
0.14, NA. 0.06
0.51, NA, 0.26
Kim et al., 2015 Gait symmetry ratio* [(Paretic swing time/paretic stance time)]/[(non-paretic swing time/non-paretic stance time)] 2.69, 2.87, 2.59
Sungkarat et al., 2011 Step length
Single-support time
Static WB
|1- (affected side/unaffected side)|
|1- (affected side/unaffected side)|
% of total body weight carried by affected limb
1.03, NA, 0.22
0.14, NA, 0.01
9.20, NA, 0.70
Tung et al., 2010 Static WB* % of total body weight supported by affected limb 4.9, NA, 1.7
Aerobic exercise (n = 3)
Lewek et al., 2018 Step length*
Stance time
Paretic/non-paretic limb
Paretic/non-paretic limb
−0.02, −0.06, −0.06
0.00, −0.01, −0.00
e Silva et al., 2017 Swing time Paretic swing time/non-paretic swing time 0.02, NA, −0.21
Escudero-Uribe et al., 2017 Step length* Not provided −1.50, −0.80, 0.40
Combined exercise (n = 1)
Kim et al., 2017 Gait symmetry ratio* [(Paretic swing time/paretic stance time)]/[(non-paretic swing time/non-paretic stance time)] −0.78, −1.9, −0.08

Δ asymmetry and symmetry outcomes: absolute change in asymmetry and symmetry outcomes from pre to post; Ex 1, experimental group 1; Ex 2, experimental group 2; Con, control group; NA, not applicable; WB, weight bearing;

*

, statistically significant within group difference; p < 0.05;

, statistically significant between group difference, p < 0.05.