Skip to main content
. 2020 Nov 25;4(1):e000859. doi: 10.1136/bmjpo-2020-000859

Table 1.

Studies and type of samples

Serial number Author (reference) Number of neonates tested Specimen tested Results: neonatal and others Positive/total tested
1. Chen et al 45 6 NP, AF, cord blood, BM Negative
2. Cao et al 67 5 NP Negative
3. Hu et al 42 7 NP, urine, AF NP +ve at 36 hours, others negative 1/7
4. Zhu et al 57 10 NP Negative(within 72 hours (8); between D7 and D9 (2))
5. Zhang et al 102 10 NP Negative
6. Penfield C et al 103 11 NP, placental and membrane NP: negative (D1 and D5)
Placenta and membrane +ve
3/11
7. Knight M et al 23 262 NP (n=244), blood or aspirate +ve at <12 hours
+ve at >12 hours
6/244
6/244
8. Kayem G et al 25 181 NP +ve 2/181
9. Nayak A et al 26 134 NP (n=131) +ve on D1, −ve on D5 3/131
10. Yan J et al 24 86 NP (n=86); cord blood (n=10), AF (n=10) Negative
11. Khan S et al 64 17 NP +ve within 24 hours 2/17
12. Zeng L et al 41 33 NP, anal swab Both +ve D2 and D4, −ve on D6 3/33
13. Breslin N et al 59 18 NP Negative
14. Breslin N et al 114 7 NP Negative
15. Qiancheng X et al 107 23 NP Negative
16. Prabhu M et al 60 71 NP Negative at 24 hours
17. Shanes E et al 36 16 NP, placenta Negative
18. Savasi V et al 109 57 NP +ve 4/57
19. London V et al 27 48 NP Negative
20. Pierce-Williams R et al 63 33 NP −ve at 24 hours, +ve at 48 hours 1/33
21. Martínez-Perez O et al 65 82 NP NP +ve at birth and negative at 48 hours (3); NP −ve at birth but +ve at D10 (2) 5/82
22. Nie R et al 68 26 NP, Cord blood, Placenta NP +ve at 36 hours, negative: all other samples, NP (D4, D8, D15) 1/26
23. Yin M et al 46 17 NP (n=17), BM (n=14), AF (n=2), placenta (n=2), anal swab (n=5)  Negative
24. Yang P et al 81 7 NP, cord blood, AF Negative
25. Yang H et al 73 55 NP Negative
26. Wu Y et al 47 5 NP, anal swab, BM Negative, BM +ve 1/5
27. Patane L et al 39 22 NP, placenta NP +ve, placenta- chronic intervillitis, PCR +ve in placenta 2/22
28. Ferrazzi E et al 28 42 NP NP +ve on D1, D3 (2)
NP equivocal at birth but +ve on D3 (1)
3/42
29. Govind A et al 61 9 NP, placenta, AF NP +ve 1/9
30. Vintzileos W et al 113 29 NP Negative
31. Baergen R et al 37 21 NP Negative
32. Zeng H et al 54 6 NP
neonatal blood
NP negative;
elevated IgM and IgG (2);
Elevated IgG, normal IgM (3)
Cytokine IL-6 elevated in all infants
33. Liu Y et al 69 10 Foetal blood Negative
34. Mulvey J et al 38 5 Placenta Negative
35. Hantoushzadeh et al 75 4 NP −ve at D1; +ve at D7 1/4
36. Buonsenso et al 53 2 NP, AF, placenta, cord blood, rectal swab, BM 1st: NP −ve on D1, D4 and +ve on D15, placenta, AF, rectal swab-negative, weak IgG +ve, IgM −ve
2nd: placenta, breast milk: +ve but cord blood negative in neonate with NP negative result
1/2
37. Fan C et al ()48 2 NP, AF, cord blood, BM, placenta, vaginal swab Negative
38. Liu W et al ()56 3 NP, cord blood,
neonatal whole blood
Negative (D2)
39. Lowe B et al ()62 1 NP Negative
40. Chen S et al ()104 3 NP, placenta Negative
41. Chen Y et al ()58 4 NP Negative
42. Gidlöf S et al ()76 2 NP Negative (34 hours and 4.5 days)
43. Khan S et al ()85 3 NP Negative
44. Schnettler W et al ()110 1 NP, AF AF −ve, NP −ve on D1, D2
45. Blauvelt C et al ()84 1 NP, rectal swab D2
IgG and IgM
NP −ve on D1, D2, D14
Rectal swab −ve on D2
IgG and IgM negative (D5)
46. Alzamora M et al ()78 1 NP, cord blood Negative for IgM and IgG; NP +ve at 16 hours and 48 hours 1/1
47. Vivanti A et al ()29 1 NP, AF, vaginal swab, NBAL, neonatal blood and rectal swabs NP +ve at 1 hour, D3, D18;
rectal swab +ve at 1 hour, D3, D18; vaginal swab, NBAL, neonatal blood, AF +ve
1/1
48. Song L et al ()49 1 NP, AF, cord blood, BM NP −ve at D3, D7
All other negative
49. Zambrano L et al ()87 1 NP Negative
50. Li Y et al ()44 1 NP, neonatal blood, faeces and urine NP negative at birth and 48 hours
All other negative
51. Dong L et al ()55 1 NP, serum
vaginal swab
IgM level elevated
NP negative at 2 hours,16 hours
1/1
52. Baud D et al ()33 1 NP, AF, placenta
vaginal swabs
 Placenta +ve
 All other negative
1/1; 2nd trimester spontaneous miscarriage
53. Wang X et al ()77 1 NP, AF, placenta, cord blood, gastric juice, faeces NP −ve at D1, D3, D7, D9
All other negative
54. Huang J et al ()86 1 NP Negative
55. Iqbal S et al ()105 1 NP Negative
56. Kalafat E et al ()79 1 NP, cord blood, Placenta Negative
57. Lee D et al ()80 1 NP, AF, cord blood, placenta, neonatal serum, anal swab  Negative
58. Liao X et al ()106 1 NP, AF, cord blood, placenta Negative
59. Xiong X et al ()50 1 NP, AF, BM, rectal swab Negative
60. Wang S et al ()51 1 NP, placenta, cord blood, BM NP +ve at 36 hours
−ve in all others
1/1
61. Zamaniyan M et al ()30 1 NP, cord blood, AF, vaginal secretion NP: −ve at 0 hour, +ve at D2, D4, D6
AF +ve, all others negative
1/1
62. Kirtsman M et al ()35 1 NP, placental, stool, BM
neonatal plasma D4
NP +ve at D1, D2, D7
Placenta +ve
Stool +ve D7, BM +ve
1/1
63. Lyra J et al()74 1 NP Negative
64. Algarroba G et al ()34 1 NP Negative at 0 hour, D2, D7
65. Peng Z et al ()43 1 NP, NBAL fluid, sputum, urine Negative
66. Groß R et al ()52 2 BM, NP Both NP +ve (>D7), BM +ve (1) 2/2,1/2
67. Perrone S et al ()72 4 NP (3), Placenta (1) NP negative on D1, placenta-negative
68. Hosier H et al ()32 1 Placenta, cord blood Both +ve 1/1; D&E at 22 weeks
69. Pulinx B et al ()31 2 AF, placental Both +ve 2/2, DCDA twin at 24 weeks
70. Yu N et al ()108 2 AF in mid pregnancy Negative
71. Kulkarni et al ()117 1 NP, placenta, cord stump, neonatal blood All +ve at 12 hours of life; serology −ve on D10 but +ve on D21 1/1
72. Sisman J et al ()70 1 NP, placenta NP +ve at 24 hours, 48 hours, D14; placenta +ve by electron microscopy 1/1

D&E- dilatation and evacuation; AF, amniotic fluid; BM, breast milk; D1, 1st day of life; D4, 4th day of life; DCDA, dichorionic diamniotic; NBAL, non-bronchoscopic broncho-alveolar lavage fluid; NP, neonatal pharyngeal/throat swab.