Adam-Poupart 1 et al (1) |
2015 |
Canada |
Working population |
Maximum daily outdoor temperature |
Ecological |
The relationship between daily counts of compensations and maximum daily temperatures reached statistical significance for three health regions. The incidence rate ratio of daily compensations per 1°C increase was 1.002 (95%CI 1.002 to 1.003). |
Bonafede et al (2) |
2016 |
Global |
Working population |
Daily maximum temperature daily mean temperature or apparent temperature |
Systematic review |
Only 2 studies analysed the dose-response relationship between temperature and the health outcomes finding a reversed U-shaped exposure-response relationship, or linear relationship or linear above/below a threshold. |
Dutta et al (3) |
2015 |
India |
Construction |
WBGT |
Cross-sectional |
Injuries reported in summer were among workers with < 36 months of experience. |
Garzon-Villalba et al (4) |
2016 |
USA |
Working population |
WBGTmax |
Incidence |
Acute injuries (AI) were higher in workers exposed above a WBGTmax of 20°C (RR 1.06/°C). The unadjusted model showed a 13% increment in risk to experience an AI when the ambient thermal conditions increase 1°C-WBGT. |
McInnes et al (5) |
2017 |
Australia |
Working population |
Maximum daily temperature and minimum daily temperature (minimum temperature during the night before the day of injury) |
Case-crossover |
Significant positive associations between temperature and acute injury were seen for younger workers, with the odds of injury increasing by 1% for each 1°C increase in daily minimum temperature, and by 0.8% for each 1°C increase in daily maximum temperature. |
Morabito et al (6) |
2006 |
Italy (Tuscany) |
Working population |
Apparent temperature (AT) AT max, AT24 and AT day were assessed |
Ecological |
The peak of work-related accidents occurred on days characterized by high, but not extreme, thermal conditions. The maximum peak of work accidents in each month occurred on days characterized by a mean ATday ranging between 24.8°C and 27.5 °C. |
Nag et al (7) |
2001 |
India |
Manufacturing industry |
Ambient temperature |
Case surveillance |
Accident prevalence was significantly high in the summer months (May-June) when the ambient temperature ranged between 42 and 48°C (hot-dry). Permanent night workers were more vulnerable and less tolerant to heat compared to the rotating day workers. |
Otte-im-Kampe et al (8) |
2016 |
High-income countries |
General population, including working population |
Not specified |
Systematic review |
Two out of 3 studies found an increase in work-related accidents during increased temperatures; the other reported no association. |
Rameezdeen et al (9) |
2017 |
Australia |
Construction |
Daily maximum and minimum temperatures |
Case-crossover |
The number of accidents reported during heat wave periods was less compared to control periods, suggesting some control measures are in operation in construction sites to prevent accidents during heat waves |
Spector et al (10) |
2016 |
USA |
Agriculture |
Maximum daily humidex exposures |
Case-crossover |
The traumatic injury OR was 1.14 (95% CI 1.06, 1.22), 1.15 (95% CI 1.06, 1.25), and 1.10 (95% CI 1.01, 1.20) for daily maximum humidex of 25±29, 30±33, and ≥34, respectively, compared to < 25, adjusted for self-reported duration of employment. |
Tawatsupa et al (11) |
2013 |
Thailand |
Working population |
Experiences of heat stress derived from survey question |
Cohort |
Nearly 20% of workers experienced occupational heat stress, which strongly and significantly associated with occupational injury (adjusted OR 2.12, 95%CI 1.87-2.42 for males and 1.89, 95%CI 1.64-2.18 for females). |
Withen (12) |
2015 |
North America |
Firefighters |
Not specified |
Narrative review |
The trend in fatalities follows that of climate change, with a general upward trend in deaths from the 1980s to the present. |
Xiang et al (13) |
2014 |
Australia |
Working population |
Daily maximum temperature |
Ecological |
A reversed U-shaped exposure-response relationship between Tmax and overall daily injury claims was observed. Overall, a 1°C increase in maximum temperature between 14.2°C and 37.7°C was associated with a 0.2% increase in daily injury claims. |
Xiang et al (14) |
2014 |
Australia |
Working population |
Daily maximum and minimum temperatures |
Time-series |
The mean Tmax during heat waves was 38.8 °C. Daily claims increased significantly by 6.2% during heatwaves for outdoor industries. Burns, wounds, lacerations, amputations and HRI were significantly associated with heatwaves. |
Xiang et al (15) |
2014 |
Global |
Working population |
25 (60%) studies used WGBT, 7 (16%) used subjective heat stress and 6 %14%) used air temperature |
Systematic review |
Manual workers are at risk of heat stress, especially those in LMIC; 79% of identified studies indicated that participants were suffering from heat strain, with outdoor workplaces (90%) being much higher than indoor workplaces (65%). |