Table 1.
Summary of Literature Included in Review of SARS-CoV-2 Viral Shedding
Study | Country | Design | Patient Population | No. of Patients | Severity of Illness | Specimen Sources | Testing Methods |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Andersson M et al6 | United Kingdom | Prospective case series | Hospitalized, outpatient, recovered | 278 | Not defined | Serum | PCR Viral culture |
Arashiro T et al60 | Japan | Case report | Hospitalized | 2 | Mild | Not specified | PCR |
Arons MM et al9 | United States | Point prevalence | Skilled nursing facility residents | 76 | Not defined | NP OP |
PCR Viral culture if PCR + |
Bullard J et al5 | Canada | Retrospective cross-sectional | Not specified | 90 | Not defined | NP ET tube |
PCR Viral culture |
Campioli C et al26 | United States | Retrospective case series | Hospitalized, outpatient | 251 | Not defined | NP | PCR |
Chang M et al46 | China | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 16 | Not defined | Throat | PCR |
Chau NVV et al18 | Vietnam | Prospective case series | Quarantine center | 30 | Asymptomatic, mild | Saliva NP |
PCR |
Chen Y et al16 | China | Retrospective cohort study | Hospitalized | 42 | Uncomplicated, mild, severe | NP Urine Stool |
PCR |
COVID-19 Investigation Team11 | United States | Retrospective case series | Mixed – hospitalized and home isolation | 12 | Not defined | OP NP Serum Stool Urine |
PCR Viral culture Whole genome sequencing |
Danzetta ML et al32 | Italy | Retrospective case series | Hospitalized and outpatient | 14,200 tested; 605 positives | Not defined | NP OP |
PCR |
Di Tian LW et al21 | China | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 75 | Mild, moderate, severe, critical | Not specified | PCR |
Fang Z et al55 | China | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 32 | ICU or non-ICU | NP Saliva Tears Blood Urine Stool |
PCR |
Fu S et al24 | China | Retrospective case series | Hospitalized | 50 | Severe | NP Throat Rectal |
PCR |
Fu Y et al27 | China | Retrospective case series | Hospitalized | 410 | Not defined | Throat | PCR |
Gombar S et al39 | United States | Retrospective case series | Not specified, but primarily outpatient | 150 | Not defined | NP | PCR |
Han J et al30 | China | Retrospective case series | Hospitalized | 185 | Mild, moderate, severe, critical | Respiratory | PCR |
He X et al64 | China | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 94 | Moderate | Throat | PCR |
Huang J et al25 | China | Retrospective case series | Hospitalized | 33 | Moderate and severe | Throat Sputum Stool |
PCR |
Huang JT et al29 | China | Retrospective case series | Hospitalized | 308 | General, severe, critically ill | Nasal Pharyngeal |
PCR |
Hung IF et al41 | Hong Kong | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 9 | Symptomatic and asymptomatic | NP Throat |
PCR |
Ikegami S et al44 | United States | Prospective case series | Outpatient | 272 | Recovered | NP | PCR |
Jiang X et al74 | China | Case report | Home isolation | 1 | Asymptomatic | NP Anal |
PCR |
Kim ES et al22 | Korea | Retrospective case series | Hospitalized | 28 | From 1 (no limit of activity) to 8 (death) | NP OP Sputum |
PCR |
Lan L et al61 | China | Prospective case series | Hospitalized Home isolation |
4 | Asymptomatic Symptomatic |
Throat | PCR |
La Scola B et al8 | France | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 155 | Not defined | NP Sputum |
PCR Viral culture |
Le TQM et al7 | Vietnam | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 12 | 1 asymptomatic, rest not specified | Throat | PCR Viral culture |
Lee S et al43 | Korea | Retrospective case series | Community treatment center | 303 | Symptomatic and asymptomatic | NP OP Sputum |
PCR |
Li N et al48 | China | Retrospective case series | Hospitalized | 36 | Mild or severe | Respiratory Saliva |
PCR |
Li J et al80 | China | Case report | Hospitalized | 1 | Mild/moderate | NP OP |
PCR |
Li W et al37 | China | Retrospective case series | Hospitalized | 18 | Asymptomatic or mild | NP Nasal Sputum Throat Anal |
PCR |
Lin A et al34 | China | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 137 | Mild or severe | Not specified | PCR |
Ling Y et al47 | China | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 66 | Not defined | OP Blood Urine Stool |
PCR |
Liu WD et al12 | Taiwan | Case report | Hospitalized | 1 | Not defined | Sputum Throat Stool |
PCR Viral culture |
Liu Y et al68 | China | Case report | Hospitalized | 1 | Severe | OP | PCR |
Liu F et al79 | China | Case report | Hospitalized | 1 | Moderate | NP | PCR |
Lo IL et al51 | China | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 10 | Mild, moderate, or severe | NP Urine Stool |
PCR |
Long QX et al38 | China | Point prevalence | Hospitalized | 178 | Asymptomatic, mild | NP | PCR |
Min C et al15 | Singapore | Retrospective case series and position statement | Not specified | 766 | Not specified | NP | PCR Viral culture |
Miyamae Y et al56 | Japan | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 23 | Asymptomatic, mild | NP OP |
PCR |
Noh JY et al35 | Korea | Retrospective case series | Residential treatment center | 199 | Asymptomatic or atypical symptoms | Not defined | PCR |
Park SY et al31 | Korea | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 6 | Not defined | NP OP Sputum Saliva |
PCR |
Park SK et al72 | Korea | Prospective case series | Outpatient | 46 | Asymptomatic and mild | Respiratory Stool |
PCR |
Pongpirul WA et al19 | Thailand | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 11 | Asymptomatic, mild, moderate | Upper respiratory | PCR |
Qi L et al54 | China | Retrospective case series | Hospitalized | 147 | Mild, moderate, or severe | Respiratory | PCR |
Qian GQ et al45 | China | Retrospective case series | Hospitalized | 24 | Not defined | Throat Rectal |
PCR |
Ridgway JP et al42 | United States | Retrospective case series | Hospitalized and outpatient | 555 | Not defined | NP | PCR |
Sakurai A et al17 | Japan | Retrospective case series | Cruise ship | 90 | Asymptomatic | NP | PCR |
Seah IYJ et al76 | Singapore | Prospective case series | Hospitalized Discharged |
17 | Not defined | Tears NP |
PCR |
Sun J et al66 | China | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 49 | Mild or severe | NP Sputum Throat Stool |
PCR |
Talmy T et al23 | Israel | Retrospective case series | Hospitalized | 219 | Mild | NP OP |
PCR |
Tan W et al70 | China | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 67 | Mild, moderate, severe | NP Sputum Blood Urine Stool |
PCR |
To KK et al62 | Hong Kong | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 23 | Mild or severe | OP Saliva |
PCR |
Van Kampen JJA et al4 | Netherlands | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 129 | Mechanically ventilated, ICU with oxygen therapy, ward with oxygen therapy, ward without oxygen therapy | NP Sputum |
PCR Viral culture |
Wang W et al71 | China | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 205 | Severe Nonsevere |
Nasal Blood Sputum Stool Urine |
PCR |
Wang J et al57 | China | Case report | Hospitalized | 1 | Mild | NP | PCR |
Wang K et al28 | China | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 68 | CURB-65 scores 1–3 |
NP Sputum |
PCR |
Wang C et al58 | China | Case report | Hospitalized | 1 | Mild | NP OP |
PCR |
Wang Y et al86 | China | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 23 | Mild and severe | NP Sputum Throat Fecal Urine Blood |
PCR |
Wölfel R et al10 | Germany | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 9 | Mild | Sputum NP Throat Stool |
PCR Viral culture Whole-genome sequencing |
Wu Y et al20 | China | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 98 | Not defined | Throat Stool |
PCR |
Xiao F et al13 | China | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 28 | Not defined | NP OP Stool |
PCR Viral culture |
Xiao AT et al53 | China | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 56 | Mild to moderate | NP Throat |
PCR |
Xu K et al52 | China | Retrospective case series | Hospitalized | 113 | Mild, pneumonia, severe pneumonia, ARDS, septic shock | Sputum NP Throat BAL |
PCR |
Young BE et al33 | Singapore | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 18 | Not defined | NP Urine Stool Blood |
PCR |
Zhang L et al69 | China | Case report | Hospitalized | 1 | Mild | Throat | PCR |
Zhang J et al.73 | China | Retrospective case series | Hospitalized | 14 | Not defined | OP Stool |
PCR |
Zhang WY et al67 | China | Case report | Hospitalized | 1 | Mild | Pharyngeal | PCR |
Zhang W et al75 | China | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 39 | Severe Nonsevere Clinical condition unknown |
Oral Rectal |
PCR |
Zhang N et al14 | China | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 23 | Mild, moderate, critical | Upper respiratory Urine Stool Blood |
PCR Viral Culture |
Zhao F et al36 | China | Retrospective case series | Hospitalized | 401 | Mild, moderate, severe | Respiratory Fecal |
PCR |
Zheng S et al50 | China | Retrospective case series | Hospitalized | 96 | Mild, severe | Respiratory Blood Urine Stool |
PCR |
Zheng X et al78 | China | Retrospective case series | Hospitalized | 80 | Common, severe | Throat Stool |
PCR |
Zhou B et al49 | China | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 41 | Severe | Throat | PCR |
Zhou F et al40 | China | Retrospective case series | Hospitalized | 191 | Mild, moderate, severe, critical | Respiratory | PCR |
Zhou R et al77 | China | Retrospective case series | Hospitalized | 31 | Asymptomatic | NP | PCR |
Yao XH et al59 | China | Case report | Hospitalized | 1 | Severe | NP Lung Liver Heart Intestine Skin |
PCR Histopathology |
Zou L et al63 | China | Prospective case series | Hospitalized | 18 | Asymptomatic, mild-to-moderate, severe | NP | PCR |
Note. NP, nasopharyngeal; OP, oropharyngeal; PCR, polymerase chain reaction; ET, endotracheal.