Skip to main content
. 2020 Nov 13;8:580226. doi: 10.3389/fped.2020.580226

Table 1.

Characteristics of included studies.

Study ID Age Surgery type Sample size Anesthesia Groups Outcome
Nidhi 2013 (12) 8–12 Y Corrective surgery 36 Sev, N2O Intubation DEX (9): 1 ug/kg iv followed by 0.5 ug/kg/h infusion; NS (9): volume-matched iv ABCDE
Bi 2019 (36) 6–48 M Fiberoptic bronchoscopy 40 Sev LMA DEX (11):1 ug/kg intranasal; NS (11):0.01 ml/kg intranasal ADE
Sun 2017 (30) 1–5 Y Laparoscopic hernia repair 97 Sev LMA DEX1(13):0.25 ug/kg iv; DEX2(14):0.5 ug/kg iv; DEX3(14):1 ug/kg iv; NS (15):2 ml iv ADEF
Boku 2015 (37) 10–14 M Palatoplasty 70 Sev, N2O Intubation DEX (17):6 ug/kg/h for 10 min, followed by 0.4 ug/kg/h; NS (17): volume-matched iv AD
Mizrak 2011 (18) 4.5–11 Y Strabismus surgery 60 Ketamine Intubation DEX (19):0.5 ug/kg iv; Placebo (19) AC
Erdil 2009 (10) 2–7 Y Adenoidectomy 90 Sev, N2O Intubation DEX (19):0.5 ug/kg iv; Fentanyl (19):2.5 ug/kg iv; NS (19): iv ADE
Guler 2005 (35) 3–7 Y Adenotonsillectomy 60 Sev, N2O Intubation DEX (19):0.5 ug/kg iv; NS (19): volume-matched iv ABDE
Cho 2020 (13) 24 M−12 Y Tonsillectomy 66 Sev Intubation DEX (21):0.3 ug/kg iv; Midazolam (22):0.03 mg/kg iv ABCDF
Li 2016 (23) 4–6 Y Tonsillectomy 80 Des Intubation DEX (24):0.2 ug/kg/h; NS (24): volume-matched iv ABCDF
Wei 2015 (9) 3–24 M Cleft palate repair 40 Sev, Propofol Remifentanil Intubation DEX (11):0.8 ug/kg/min; NS (11): volume-matched iv ABDE
Bhat 2018 (26) 1–8 Y Inguinal hernia 90 Sev, N2O LMA DEX1(19):0.5 ug/kg iv; DEX2(19):1 ug/kg iv; NS (19):5 ml iv AEF
Ahmed 2017 (15) 3–7 Y Tonsillectomy and/or Adenoidectomy 86 Sev Intubation DEX (41):1 ug/kg intranasal; NS (41):1 ml intranasal ABCDEF
Song 2016 (22) 2–6 Y Strabismus surgery 103 Sev, N2O LMA DEX1(14):0.25 ug/kg iv; DEX2(14):0.5 ug/kg iv; DEX3v (27):1 ug/kg iv; NS (14): iv ACDF
Ali 2016 (11) 3–6 Y Orthopedic surgery 90 Sev Intubation DEX (19):0.3 ug/kg iv; Ketofol (19): ketamine 0.25 mg/kg and Propofol 1 mg/kg iv; NS (19):10 ml iv AD
Mukherjee 2015 (19) 3–7 Y Day care surgery 80 Sev Intubation DEX (24):1 ug/kg intranasal; Clonidine (24):4 ug/kg intranasal ABCDEF
Liu 2015 (27) 2–12 Y Achilles-tendon lengthening 80 Sev Intubation DEX (24):0.5 ug/kg iv; NS (24):10 ml iv ADEF
Sheta 2014 (28) 3–6 Y Dental rehabilitation 72 Sev, N2O Intubation DEX (29):1 ug/kg intranasal; Midazolam (29):0.2 mg/kg ABCE
Ali 2013 (8) 2–6 Y Adenotonsillectomy 120 Sev, N2O Intubation DEX (24):0.3 ug/kg iv; Propofol (24):1 mg/kg iv; NS (24):10 ml iv ABDEF
Meng 2012 (31) 5–14 Y Tonsillectomy 120 Sev Intubation DEX1 (24):0.5 ug/kg iv followed by 0.2 ug/kg/h; DEX2 (24):1 ug/kg followed by 0.4 ug/kg/h; lactated Ringer (24): iv ADEF
Xu 2012 (32) 3–7 Y Vitreoretinal surgery 60 Sev, Remifentanil Intubation DEX (19):0.5 ug/kg, iv; NS (19):10 ml iv ADE
Asaad 2011 (33) 5–10 Y Elective surgery 88 Sev, N2O Intubation DEX (19):0.15 ug/kg, iv; Fentanyl (27):1 ug/kg; NS (19):10 ml iv AEF
Ibacache 2004 (14) 1–10 Y Inguinal hernia repair, orchiopexy, or circumcision 90 Sev, N2O LMA DEX1(19):0.15 ug/kg, iv; DEX2(19):1 ug/kg; NS (19):10 ml iv AEF
Olutoye 2011 (34) 3–12 Y Tonsillectomy and adenoidectomy 109 Sev, N2O Intubation DEX1(23):0.75 ug/kg, iv; DEX2(32):1 ug/kg,iv;Morphine1(19):50 ug/kg iv; Morphine2(23):100 ug/kg iv AB
Li 2018 (25) 2–7 Y Adenoidectomy with or without tonsillectomy 90 Propofol, Remifentanil Intubation DEX1(19):1 ug/kg, iv; DEX2(19):2 ug/kg, iv; NS (19):1 ml iv A
Kim 2014 (16) 1–5 Y Strabismus Surgery 94 Des Intubation DEX (42):0.2 ug/kg/h; NS (42): iv ACDEF
Patel 2010 (20) 2–10 Y Tonsillectomy and adenoidectomy 122 Sev, N2O Intubation DEX (61):2 ug/kg followed by 0.7 ug/kg/h; Fentanyl (61):1 ug/kg iv ACDE
Koceroglu 2020 (21) 2–9 Y Adenotonsillectomy 60 Sev, N2O Intubation DEX (19):1 ug/kg iv; Tramadol (19):1.5 mg/kg iv ABDE
Akin 2011 (17) 2–9 Y Adenotonsillectomy 90 Sev, N2O Intubation DEX (43):1 ug/kg intranasal; Midazolam (43):0.2 mg/kg intranasal ABCD
Kim 2014 (38) 1–5 Y Hernioplasty or orchiopexy 40 Sev LMA DEX (11):1 ug/kg followed by 0.1 ug/kg/h; NS (11): same amount IV AD
Shukry 2005 (39) 1–10 Y Outpatient surgery 46 Sev Intubation DEX (13):0.2 ug/kg/h infusion; NS (13): volume-matched iv ADF
Surana 2017 (40) 6 M-12 Y Cleft palate surgery 60 Iso, N2O Intubation DEX (19):1 ug/kg followed by 0.5 ug/kg/h; Midazolam (19):0.05 mg/kg iv ACDE
Tsiotou 2018 (24) 3–14 Y Tonsillectomy 60 Propofol, Remifentanil Intubation DEX (28):1 ug/kg iv; NS (31):50 ml iv ACD
Bhadla 2013 (29) 5–12 Y Ophthalmic day-care surgery 60 Iso Intubation DEX (19):0.4 ug/kg iv; Midazolam (19):0.04 mg/kg iv A

A, emergence agitation; B, PONV; C, requiring rescue anesthetic; D, extubation time; E, emergence time; F, Time to discharge from the PACU; M, months; Y, years; DEX, dexmedetomidine; NS, normal saline; LMA, laryngeal mask airway; Sev, sevoflurane; Des, desflurane; Iso, isoflurane.