Skip to main content
. 2020 Nov 6;9(11):2428. doi: 10.3390/cells9112428

Table 1.

Low molecular weight substances increased in CKD and examined for causal effects on cardiovascular calcification or associated readouts.

Effect Substance Species Tissue or Cell Type Type of Study Analysis of
Calcification or Calcification-Associated Process * by
Reference Plasma Level in CKD Classified as Uremic Toxin **
In Vitro Animal
INHIBITION Asymmetric dimethylarginine (ADMA) Human VSMC V $ Alizarin red staining Schepers [29] ↑ [§] V
Symmetric dimethylarginine (SDMA) Human VSMC V $ Alizarin red staining Schepers [29] ↑ [§] V
Guanidinosuccinic acid (GSA) Human VSMC V $ Alizarin red staining Schepers [29] ↑ [§] V
INDUCTION Phosphate (P) Human VSMC V Calcium content
Alizarin red staining
Bouabdallah [30] ↑ [31]
Human VSMC V Alizarin red staining
Upregulation of MSX2, SOX9 and OPN
Increased apoptosis
Cazana-Perez [32]
Human VSMC V Calcium content
Upregulation of CBFA1/RUNX2 and BMP2
Guerrero [33]
Human VSMC V Alizarin red staining Schepers [29]
Human VSMC V $ High binding affinity of calcium to ECM Shigematsu [34] 1
Rat VSMC V Von Kossa staining Shibata [35]
Rat Aorta V Calcium content Guerrero [33]
Mouse Aorta V 2 Von Kossa staining Belmokhtar [36]
Mouse VSMC V Alizarin red staining
Increased ROS generation Upregulation of PIT-1, BMP2 and CBFA1/RUNX2
Belmokhtar [36]
Mouse VSMC V Upregulation of BMP2 and OPN Sage [37] 1
Rat Aorta V 3 Von Kossa staining Shibata [35]
Calcium Rat Aorta V Calcium content Azpiazu [38] 1 ↑ [39]
Human VSMC V Calcium content Yang [40] 1
Cytidine Human MSC V $ ALP activity
Calcium content
Hegner [41] ↑ [§] V
Urea Human MSC V $ ALP activity
Calcium content
Hegner [41] ↑ [§] V
Threitol Human MSC V $ ALP activity
Calcium content
Hegner [41] ↑ [§] V
NO EFFECT Guanidino compounds: Human VSMC V Alizarin red staining Schepers [29]
ADMA ↑ [§] V
SDMA ↑ [§] V
GSA ↑ [§] V
Creatine ↑ [§] V
Creatinine ↑ [§] V
Guanidine ↑ [§] V
Guanidino acetic acid ↑ [§] V
Guanidino butyric acid ↑ [§] V
Guanidino propionic acid ↑ [§] V
Methylguanidine ↑ [§] V

ALP—alkaline phosphatase; BMP2—bone morphogenetic protein 2; CBFA1/RUNX2—core-binding factor subunit alpha-1/runt-related transcription factor 2; CT—computed tomography; ECM—extracellular matrix; MSC–mesenchymal stromal cells (as progenitors of VSMC); MSX2—msh homeobox 2; OPN—osteopontin; PIT-1—sodium Pi co-transporter-1; ROS—reactive oxygen species; SOX9—SRY-box transcription factor 9; VSMC—vascular smooth muscle cells. * Readouts of calcification-associated processes, such as cell signaling and gene/protein expression, are shown in italic. [§] As described in comprehensive uremic toxins reviews [19,20]. ** As described in comprehensive uremic toxins reviews [19,20,21]. $ In pro-calcifying medium. 1 Literature added manually after checking reference lists of included studies or recent reviews. 2 In vivo mouse model: 5/6 nephrectomy in Apoe−/−mice on a high- phosphorus diet vs. 5/6 nephrectomy in Apoe-/- mice on a control diet for twelve weeks. 3 In vivo rat model: 5/6 nephrectomy in rats on a high- phosphorus and low-calcium diet vs. 5/6 nephrectomy in rats on a control diet for eight weeks; ↑ indicates increased plasma levels in CKD patients.