Table 2.
Shoot (SDM), root (RDM) and nodule (NDM) dry mass, number of nodules per plant (NN) nitrogen content in the shoots (NCS), nitrogen accumulated in the shoots (NAS) of cowpea cv. BRS Pujante inoculated individually with 12 Bradyrhizobium spp. or co-inoculated (dual inoculation) with B. pachyrhizi BR 3262 and 11 Bradyrhizobium spp. of two experiments under the gnotobiotic condition (45 days after the emergence) and in non-sterile soil (52 days after the emergence) as substrates
| Inoculation treatment | SDM | RDM | NN | NDM | NCS | NAS | SDM | RDM | NN | NDM | NCS | NAS |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| g plant−1 | nod plant−1 | mg plant−1 | mg N g−1 | mg N plant−1 | g plant−1 | nod plant−1 | mg plant−1 | mg N g−1 | mg N plant−1 | |||
| Gnotobiotic experiment (sterile sandas substrate) | Non-sterileconditions experiment (soilas substrate) | |||||||||||
| ESA 124 | 2.06a | 1.66a | 212b | 307a | 45c | 94c | 2.00a | 1.06b | 134c | 197c | 40b | 82b |
| ESA 162 | 2.30a | 1.29a | 189b | 289a | 52c | 119b | 1.25a | 0.89b | 142c | 219c | 55b | 64b |
| ESA 168 | 2.04a | 1.22a | 164b | 208a | 49c | 106b | 1.98a | 1.12b | 200c | 277b | 71a | 150a |
| ESA 173 | 1.94a | 1.30a | 118b | 173a | 41c | 79c | 1.47a | 0.62b | 46d | 96d | 35b | 50b |
| ESA 192 | 1.43b | 1.22a | 164b | 222a | 48c | 69c | 1.55a | 0.93b | 195c | 259b | 78a | 121b |
| ESA 369 | 1.12b | 1.14b | 205b | 167a | 45c | 51c | 1.32a | 0.93b | 149c | 221c | 61b | 82b |
| ESA 376 | 1.19b | 1.34a | 197b | 302a | 48c | 57c | 2.26a | 1.26a | 255b | 381a | 70a | 165a |
| ESA 380 | 1.12b | 1.21a | 137b | 132a | 49c | 55c | 1.79a | 0.99b | 235b | 378a | 46b | 89b |
| ESA 386 | 1.13b | 1.13b | 109b | 166a | 47c | 53d | 1.61a | 0.81b | 189c | 286b | 47b | 77b |
| ESA 387 | 1.51b | 1.23a | 173b | 244a | 52c | 78c | 1.43a | 0.57b | 162c | 298b | 57b | 83b |
| BR 3267 | 1.94a | 1.38a | 166b | 172a | 62b | 118b | 1.59a | 1.51a | 165c | 162c | 42b | 67b |
| BR 3262 | 1.80a | 1.50a | 169b | 206a | 61b | 111b | 1.99a | 1.58a | 146c | 205c | 54b | 113b |
| ESA 124 + bR 3262 | 2.42a | 1.72a | 170b | 202a | 63b | 153a | 1.90a | 1.52a | 315b | 296b | 76a | 145a |
| ESA 162 + bR 3262 | 2.39a | 1.85a | 195b | 190a | 64b | 154a | 1.81a | 1.54a | 308b | 513a | 74a | 132a |
| ESA 168 + bR 3262 | 2.13a | 1.90a | 191b | 176a | 65b | 133b | 1.21a | 1.51a | 268b | 234c | 90a | 109b |
| ESA 173 + bR 3262 | 2.23a | 1.33a | 170b | 172a | 63b | 141b | 2.02a | 1.42a | 271b | 270b | 73a | 149a |
| ESA 192 + bR 3262 | 2.48a | 1.40a | 172b | 191a | 67a | 165a | 1.99a | 1.46a | 284b | 318b | 77a | 155a |
| ESA 369 + bR 3262 | 2.28a | 2.22a | 306a | 333a | 61b | 139b | 2.69a | 1.26a | 275b | 285b | 68a | 194a |
| ESA 376 + bR 3262 | 2.26a | 1.10b | 156b | 200a | 56c | 127b | 2.18a | 1.38a | 291b | 307b | 81a | 176a |
| ESA 380 + bR 3262 | 2.47a | 1.26a | 192b | 211a | 61b | 152a | 2.04a | 1.20a | 373a | 417a | 86a | 177a |
| ESA 386 + bR 3262 | 2.18a | 1.70a | 192b | 219a | 54c | 121b | 2.08a | 1.18a | 417a | 406a | 95a | 194a |
| ESA 387 + bR 3262 | 2.43a | 1.36a | 156b | 186a | 72a | 172a | 2.68a | 1.29a | 322b | 290b | 90a | 247a |
| BR 3267 + bR 3262 | 2.43a | 2.19a | 266b | 338a | 76a | 185a | 2.44a | 1.17a | 149c | 252b | 60b | 145a |
| N-fertilization* | 2.62a | 1.30b | 0c | 0b | 64b | 166a | 2.08a | 0.83b | 6d | 3d | 85a | 179a |
| Negativecontrol | 0.54c | 1.09c | 0c | 0b | 30d | 34 e | 1.44a | 0.98b | 34d | 60d | 28c | 40c |
| CV (%) | 13.7 | 16.5 | 18.2 | 13.4 | 12.2 | 14.7 | 13.9 | 12.9 | 16.4 | 10.4 | 13.4 | 18.2 |
Data are an average of four replications
Means followed by the same letter, in the same variable and in the same experiment, do not differ by the Scott–Knott mean range test (p < 0.05). CV coefficient of variation
*80 mg of N-NH4NO3 week−1, from the second to the fifth week; ** 100 mg of N-NH4NO3 week−1, from the second to the fifth week