Skip to main content
. 2020 Nov 27;11(1):4. doi: 10.1007/s13205-020-02534-5

Table 2.

Shoot (SDM), root (RDM) and nodule (NDM) dry mass, number of nodules per plant (NN) nitrogen content in the shoots (NCS), nitrogen accumulated in the shoots (NAS) of cowpea cv. BRS Pujante inoculated individually with 12 Bradyrhizobium spp. or co-inoculated (dual inoculation) with B. pachyrhizi BR 3262 and 11 Bradyrhizobium spp. of two experiments under the gnotobiotic condition (45 days after the emergence) and in non-sterile soil (52 days after the emergence) as substrates

Inoculation treatment SDM RDM NN NDM NCS NAS SDM RDM NN NDM NCS NAS
g plant−1 nod plant−1 mg plant−1 mg N g−1 mg N plant−1 g plant−1 nod plant−1 mg plant−1 mg N g−1 mg N plant−1
Gnotobiotic experiment (sterile sandas substrate) Non-sterileconditions experiment (soilas substrate)
ESA 124 2.06a 1.66a 212b 307a 45c 94c 2.00a 1.06b 134c 197c 40b 82b
ESA 162 2.30a 1.29a 189b 289a 52c 119b 1.25a 0.89b 142c 219c 55b 64b
ESA 168 2.04a 1.22a 164b 208a 49c 106b 1.98a 1.12b 200c 277b 71a 150a
ESA 173 1.94a 1.30a 118b 173a 41c 79c 1.47a 0.62b 46d 96d 35b 50b
ESA 192 1.43b 1.22a 164b 222a 48c 69c 1.55a 0.93b 195c 259b 78a 121b
ESA 369 1.12b 1.14b 205b 167a 45c 51c 1.32a 0.93b 149c 221c 61b 82b
ESA 376 1.19b 1.34a 197b 302a 48c 57c 2.26a 1.26a 255b 381a 70a 165a
ESA 380 1.12b 1.21a 137b 132a 49c 55c 1.79a 0.99b 235b 378a 46b 89b
ESA 386 1.13b 1.13b 109b 166a 47c 53d 1.61a 0.81b 189c 286b 47b 77b
ESA 387 1.51b 1.23a 173b 244a 52c 78c 1.43a 0.57b 162c 298b 57b 83b
BR 3267 1.94a 1.38a 166b 172a 62b 118b 1.59a 1.51a 165c 162c 42b 67b
BR 3262 1.80a 1.50a 169b 206a 61b 111b 1.99a 1.58a 146c 205c 54b 113b
ESA 124 + bR 3262 2.42a 1.72a 170b 202a 63b 153a 1.90a 1.52a 315b 296b 76a 145a
ESA 162 + bR 3262 2.39a 1.85a 195b 190a 64b 154a 1.81a 1.54a 308b 513a 74a 132a
ESA 168 + bR 3262 2.13a 1.90a 191b 176a 65b 133b 1.21a 1.51a 268b 234c 90a 109b
ESA 173 + bR 3262 2.23a 1.33a 170b 172a 63b 141b 2.02a 1.42a 271b 270b 73a 149a
ESA 192 + bR 3262 2.48a 1.40a 172b 191a 67a 165a 1.99a 1.46a 284b 318b 77a 155a
ESA 369 + bR 3262 2.28a 2.22a 306a 333a 61b 139b 2.69a 1.26a 275b 285b 68a 194a
ESA 376 + bR 3262 2.26a 1.10b 156b 200a 56c 127b 2.18a 1.38a 291b 307b 81a 176a
ESA 380 + bR 3262 2.47a 1.26a 192b 211a 61b 152a 2.04a 1.20a 373a 417a 86a 177a
ESA 386 + bR 3262 2.18a 1.70a 192b 219a 54c 121b 2.08a 1.18a 417a 406a 95a 194a
ESA 387 + bR 3262 2.43a 1.36a 156b 186a 72a 172a 2.68a 1.29a 322b 290b 90a 247a
BR 3267 + bR 3262 2.43a 2.19a 266b 338a 76a 185a 2.44a 1.17a 149c 252b 60b 145a
N-fertilization* 2.62a 1.30b 0c 0b 64b 166a 2.08a 0.83b 6d 3d 85a 179a
Negativecontrol 0.54c 1.09c 0c 0b 30d 34 e 1.44a 0.98b 34d 60d 28c 40c
CV (%) 13.7 16.5 18.2 13.4 12.2 14.7 13.9 12.9 16.4 10.4 13.4 18.2

Data are an average of four replications

Means followed by the same letter, in the same variable and in the same experiment, do not differ by the Scott–Knott mean range test (p < 0.05). CV coefficient of variation

*80 mg of N-NH4NO3 week−1, from the second to the fifth week; ** 100 mg of N-NH4NO3 week−1, from the second to the fifth week