Table 2.
EV QC | PD vs. ctrl | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Source | Cohort | EV Isolation Method | NTA | TEM | EV Markers |
Biomarker | Result | Statistics | Reference |
CSF | PD: 76 Ctrl: 58 |
Differential centrifugation | x | x | +; - | α-syn | ↓ | p < 0.05 | [95] |
PD: 9 Ctrl: 9 |
CD11b immunocapture | α-syn | ↑ | p < 0.05 | [101] | ||||
Oligomeric α-syn | |||||||||
Fibrillar α-syn | = | ns | |||||||
Plasma | PD: 267 Ctrl: 215 |
L1CAM immunocapture | x | + | α-syn Ratio EV α-syn/plasma α-syn |
↑ | AUC: 0.654 | [158] | |
AUC: 0.657 | |||||||||
PD: 39 Ctrl: 33 |
Differential centrifugation | x | x | +; - | α-syn Ratio EV α-syn/plasma α-syn |
↑ | p < 0.001 | [118] | |
PD: 20 Ctrl: 15 |
Differential centrifugation | x | +; - | α-syn | ↑ | p = 0.02 | [103] | ||
Monomeric and oligomeric α-syn | p = 0.0002; p < 0.0001 | ||||||||
Fibrillar α-syn | = | ns | |||||||
PD: 39 Ctrl: 40 |
ExoQuick + immunoprecipitation with L1CAM |
x | α-syn | ↑ | AUC: 0.654 | [159] | |||
DJ-1 | AUC: 0.703 | ||||||||
Ratio EV DJ-1/plasma DJ-1 | AUC: 0.724 | ||||||||
PD: 16 Ctrl: 8 |
Size exclusion chromatography | x | + | Clusterin | ↓ | p < 0.05 | [161] | ||
Complement C1r | |||||||||
Apolipoprotein A1 | |||||||||
PD: 52 Ctrl: 48 |
PureExo exosome isolation kit | x | + | miR-331-5p | ↑ | AUC: 0.849 | [162] | ||
miR-505 | ↓ | AUC: 0.898 | |||||||
Serum | PD: 14 Ctrl: 14 |
Differential centrifugation | x | x | +; - | α-syn | ↑ | p < 0.05 | [104] |
Monomeric and oligomeric α-syn | - | ||||||||
pS129 α-syn | |||||||||
TNF-α and IL-1β | p < 0.05 | ||||||||
PD: 230 Ctrl: 144 |
Differential centrifugation + immunoprecipitation with L1CAM |
x | + | α-syn | ↑ | AUC: 0.86 | [160] | ||
Clusterin | = | ns | |||||||
PD: 22 Ctrl: 18 |
Size exclusion chromatography | x | +; - | Raman spectrum | ≠ | AUC: 0.71 | [163] | ||
PD: 36 Ctrl: 36 |
Differential centrifugation | x | x | +; - | Protein composition | ≠ | NA | [156] | |
PD: 20 Ctrl: 10 |
Differential centrifugation | Protein composition | ≠ | NA | [164] | ||||
PD: 16 Ctrl: 12 |
Differential centrifugation | x | +; - | ATP5A | ↓ | p < 0.0001 | [157,165] | ||
NDUFS3 | |||||||||
SDHB | |||||||||
PD: 109 Ctrl: 40 |
Total exosome isolation reagent | + | miR-24 | ↑ | AUC: 0.908 | [166] | |||
miR-195 | AUC: 0.697 | ||||||||
miR-19b | ↓ | AUC: 0.753 | |||||||
Urine | PD: 20 Ctrl: 15 |
Differential centrifugation | x | + | LRKK2 | = | ns | [167] | |
PD: 26 Ctrl: 21 |
Microfiltration | + | DJ-1 | ↑ (only in males) | p = 0.0493 | [168] | |||
LRKK2 | = | ns | |||||||
LRKK2+ PD: 21 LRKK2- PD: 20 LRKK2+ noPD: 16 |
Differential centrifugation | + | Ratio pSer1292 LRKK2/total LRKK2 | LRKK2+ PD/LRKK2- PD: ↑ | AUC: 1 | [169] | |||
LRKK2+ PD/LRKK2+ noPD: ↑ | AUC: 0.844 | ||||||||
PD: 79 Ctrl: 79 |
Differential centrifugation | x | + | pSer1292 LRKK2 | ↑ | p = 0.0014 | [170] | ||
PD: 28 Ctrl: 22 |
Differential centrifugation | x | x | SNAP23 | ↑ | AUC: 0.8 | [171] | ||
Calbindin | AUC: 0.75 | ||||||||
Saliva | PD: 74 Ctrl: 60 |
XYCQ EV enrichment kit | x | x | + | α-syn | = | ns | [172] |
pS129 α-syn | |||||||||
Oligomeric α-syn | ↑ | AUC: 0.941 | |||||||
Ratio α-syn/oligomeric α-syn | AUC: 0.772 | ||||||||
PD: 18 Ctrl: 5 |
PEG precipitation | x | + | α-syn | ↑ | p < 0.0004 | [173] | ||
L1CAM | p < 0.0001 |
This table only discusses results obtained in Parkinson’s disease (PD) patients and controls (ctrl). In the extracellular vesicle (EV) markers column, the + symbol indicates the assessment of typical EV markers whereas the—symbol indicates the assessment of non-EV markers. For statistics, preferably the area under the receiver operating curve (AUC) or alternatively the sensitivity (sens) and specificity (spec) or p-value are indicated. Abbreviations: QC, quality control; NTA, nanoparticle tracking analysis; TEM, transmission electron microscopy; CSF, cerebrospinal fluid; L1CAM, L1 cell adhesion molecule; α-syn, alpha synuclein; TNF-α, tumor necrosis factor α; IL-1β, interleukin 1 β; NA, not applicable; ATP5A, adenosine triphosphate 5A; NDUFS3, NADH:ubiquinone oxidoreductase subunit S3; SDHB, succinate dehydrogenase complex iron sulfur subunit B; LRKK2, leucine-rich repeat kinase 2; SNAP23, synaptosomal-associated protein 23.