Skip to main content
. 2020 Nov 20;21(22):8807. doi: 10.3390/ijms21228807

Table 2.

Summary of commonly used molecular assays for the detection of ESR1 mutations.

Detection Method Principle Advantage Limitation
NGS platforms
  • Massive parallel sequencing (mostly second generation)

  • Higher throughput and faster time than Sanger sequencing

  • Detecting more dynamic range of genetic alterations than ddPCR

  • Time-consuming for data analysis

  • Necessity of special knowledge for bioinformatics

Illumina
  • Amplification: Bridge PCR

  • Sequencing: Synthesis using fluorescently labelled reversible terminator

  • Detection: bases from individual images using camera

  • Higher throughput and accuracy than Ion Torrent because of the addition of a single base at a time reducing the homopolymer sequencing error

  • Partial overlap between emission spectra of the fluorophores and losing activity of fluorescent dyes limiting the base calling

Ion Torrent
  • Amplification: Emulsion PCR

  • Sequencing: Semi-conductor sequencing utilizing hydrogen ion detection

  • Detection: signals using ion sensor on the complementary metal-oxide-semiconductor chip

  • Longer reads and easier preparation and more direct, rapid, and less expensive than Illumina relying on laser scanners

  • Relatively low output and higher raw error rate due to vulnerability to insertions/deletions (indels) errors associated with homopolymeric stretches and repeats when compared to Illumina

ddPCR
  • Partitioning the reaction through water-oil emulsion droplets (emulsion-based digital PCR) or a chip with micro-channels (microfluidics-based digital PCR)

  • Identified of target sequences using fluorescence and subsequent calculation the initial copy number and concentration of target molecules

  • Application to the detection of circulating tumor DNA based on high sensitivity with a detection limitation of 0.001%

  • Absolute quantification via micro-partitioning

  • Increase of the tolerance of PCR system to inhibitors because of the numerous micro-compartments

  • Highly readable two-dimensional data

  • Reliable results with small amount of samples because of the elimination error from pre-amplification

  • High repeatability results based on its independence on amplification efficiency

  • Lower cost compared to NGS platforms

  • Narrow dynamic range for genetic alterations compared to NGS technology

  • Relatively higher cost than real-time quantitative PCR

NGS, next-generation sequencing; ddPCR, droplet digital polymerase chain reaction.