Skip to main content
. 2020 Dec 2;15(12):e0242702. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0242702

Table 2. Main results of the eligible studies.

Study Diagnosis Specimen type OPN variants Cases Controls Unit Detection method
Mean SD N Mean SD N
Shiratori B 2014 PTB Plasma NR 150.73 53.43 37 74.23 19.34 30 ng/mL ELISA
Shiratori B 2017 PTB Plasma Full-length and cleaved OPN 59.46 37.70 36 40.05 27.72 19 ng/mL ELISA
Inomata SI 2003 PTB Plasma Full-length OPN 433.0 259.0 47 170.0 65.9 25 ng/mL ELISA
Zhang YT 2018 PTB Serum NR 657.5 315.6 48 170.3 114.2 53 ng/mL ELISA
Wu TF 2017 Spinal tuberculosis Serum NR 538.94 258.41 51 143.12 78.31 63 ng/mL ELISA
Ding YL 2017 PTB Plasma NR 563.2 123.4 20 40.2 11.2 20 ng/mL ELISA
Hao XL 2016 Smear-negative PTB Serum NR 712.62 335.75 43 185.34 120.23 40 pg/mL ELISA
Cui JX 2014 PTB Serum NR 588.42 271.67 80 169.12 97.43 100 ng/mL ELISA
Guo SX 2013 PTB Serum NR 683.21 321.76 42 168.46 117.31 36 ng/mL ELISA
Gan B 2009 TB Plasma NR 160.54 32.42 44 76.18 20.69 20 ng/mL ELISA
Du H 2020 PTB Serum NR 564.52 126.51 50 40.26 11.72 20 ng/mL ELISA
Wang Q 2019 PTB Serum NR 663.45 94.20 92 384.14 37.15 50 ng/mL ELISA
Wu YX 2019 PTB Serum NR 663.9 282.6 90 356.4 130.2 90 pg/mL ELISA
Feng PL 2017 PTB Serum NR 691.54 102.72 55 171.94 36.83 60 ng/mL ELISA
Yuan Y 2016 PTB Serum NR 683.2 321.8 52 168.5 117.3 45 ng/mL ELISA
Qiao YF 2013 PTB Serum NR 652.4 270.8 62 155.6 107.2 35 ng/mL ELISA
Sun XX 2016 PTB Serum NR 652.31 264.74 84 152.93 113.26 80 ng/L ELISA

PTB, pulmonary tuberculosis; TB, tuberculosis; SD, standard deviation; NR, not reported; ELISA, enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay.