Table 1.
Summary of design and characteristics of studies included in the meta-analysis.
Study | Design | Location | Hospitalization | Exposure | Mortality |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Arshad 2020 | Observational Cohort | USA | Hospitalized | HCQ (n = 1202) vs. HCQ + AZI (n = 783) vs. AZI (n = 147) vs. Control (n = 409) | 162/1202 vs. 157/783 vs. 33/147 vs. 108/409 |
Cavalcanti 2020 | RCT | Brazil | Hospitalized | HCQ (n = 159) vs. HCQ + AZI (n = 172) vs. Control (n = 173) | 5/159 vs. 3/172 vs. 5/173 |
Di Castelnuovo 2020 | Observational Cohort | Italy | Hospitalized | HCQ (n = 2634) vs. Control (n = 817) | 386/2634 vs. 190/817 |
Geleris 2020 | Observational Cohort | USA | Hospitalized | HCQ ± AZI (n = 811) vs. No HCQ ± AZI (n = 565) | 157/811 vs. 75/565 |
Horby 2020 | RCT | UK | Hospitalized | HCQ (n = 1561) vs. Control (n = 3155) | 421/1561 vs. 790/3155 |
Ip 2020 | Observational Cohort | USA | Hospitalized | HCQ ± AZI (n = 1914) vs. Control ± AZI (n = 598) | 432/1914 vs. 115/598 |
Magagnoli 2020 | Observational Cohort | USA | Hospitalized | HCQ (n = 97) vs. HCQ + AZI (n = 113) vs. Control (n = 158) | 27/97 vs. 25/113 vs. 18/158 |
Mahevas 2020 | Observational Cohort | France | Hospitalized | HCQ (n = 84) vs. Control (n = 97) | 3/84 vs. 4/97 |
Membrillo 2020 | Observational Cohort | Spain | Hospitalized | HCQ (n = 123) vs. Control (n = 43) | 27/123 vs. 21/43 |
Paccoud 2020 | Observational Cohort | France | Hospitalized | HCQ (n = 38) vs. Control (n = 46) | 3/38 vs. 6/46 |
Rosenberg 2020 | Observational Cohort | USA | Hospitalized | HCQ (n = 271) vs. HCQ + AZI (n = 735) vs. AZI (n = 211) vs. Control (n = 221) | 54/271 vs. 189/735 vs. 21/211 vs. 28/221 |
Sibidian 2020 | Observational Cohort | France | Hospitalized | HCQ (n = 623) vs. HCQ + AZI (n = 227) vs. Control (3792) | 126/623 vs. 56/227 vs. 865/3792 |
Singh 2020 | Observational Cohort | USA | Hospitalized | HCQ (n = 1125) vs. Control (n = 2247) | 104/910 vs. 109/910 |
Yu 2020 | Observational Cohort | China | Hospitalized | HCQ (n = 48) vs. Control (n = 520) | 9/48 vs. 238/520 |
AZI: Azithromycin, HCQ: Hydroxychloroquine, RCT: Randomized Clinical Trial.