Table 1.
Virus Type | Retrovirus and Lentivirus | Adenovirus | Poxvirus | Alphavirus | Arenavirus | Herpesvirus | Flavivirus | Paramyxovirus | Rhabdovirus |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Forms in development | Replication-defective Integrase-defective Single-cycle |
Replication-competent Replication-defective |
Replication-defective Replication-competent |
Replication-competent Replication-defective Single-cycleReplicon |
Reverse genetics system Replication-competent |
Replication-defective Single-cycle |
Replication-competent | Reverse genetics system Replication-competent |
Replication-competent Single-cycle |
Commonly used vectors | Moloney murine leukemia virus vector | RD-Ad5 SC-Ad6 |
Modified vaccinia virus Ankara Fowlpox Canarypox |
Sindbis virus (SIN) Semliki Forest virus (SFV) Venezuelan equine encephalitis (VEE) |
Lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus Pichinde virus |
Cytomegalovirus Turkey herpesvirus |
YF-17D Yellow fever virus 17D (YF-17D) |
Avian paramyxovirus serotype (APMV)-1 APMV-3 |
Vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) Rabies |
Main advantages | Large packaging capacity Integrating ability Transducing non-dividing cells Ability to be pseudotyped |
Broad tropism Variety of systemsdeveloped and tested Strong gene expression |
Large packaging capacity Ability to induce a strong cellular immune response Broad host range |
Broad tropism Ability to produce a large amount of heterologous protein while maintaining high titers |
Low seroprevalence Ability to induce low antiviral immunity Targeting and infection of antigen presenting cells |
Large packaging ability Capable of superinfecting a host Induces a long-lived T cell response Ease of manipulation |
Ability to induce strong and long lasting adaptive immune response Relatively broad tropism |
Does not undergo recombination so the vector is genetically stable Broad tropism Replication is generally limited to the respiratory tract |
Ability to induce a robust humoral immune response Lack of preexisting immunity in generalpopulation Ability to be pseudotyped |
Disadvantages | Concerns over insertional mutagenesis | Preexisting immunity to human adenoviral species like Ad5 | Inability to induce strong immune responses in clinical trials | Transient gene expression so not useful for diseases that require long-term therapeutics | Needs further testing to ensure safety in humans | Causes lifelong infections in hosts so needs to be attenuated | Low immunogenicity of recombinant vectors and vector instability | Needs further testing to ensure safety in humans | Potential of neuro-virulence for rabies virus vector |
Insert capacity | 8 kB | 8 kB | >25 kB | 18 kB | 4 kB | >30 kB | 6 kB | 4.5 kB | 6 kB |
References | [7,8,9] | [10,11,12,13,14] | [15,16,17,18] | [19,20] | [21,22,23] | [24,25,26,27] | [28,29] | [30,31] | [32,33,34,35] |