Table 1.
Taxonomy of critical points to performance measurement in public health and primary care system
Domains | Sub-domains/categories | References | |
---|---|---|---|
Leadership and Stewardship[6,30,31,32] | Strategic planning[33] | Vision | [34] |
Mission | [14] | ||
Forming health policies, determining prospects and strategies | [6] | ||
Approaches for controlling and adjusting | |||
Accountability system and inter-sectoral co-operation | |||
Organizing healthcare service delivery | |||
Funding[6,31,32,34,39] | Fair financing | [11,31] | |
Costs/Expenditure | [10,13,17,30] | ||
Revenue collection | [6] | ||
Integrating and allocation the resources to state budget | |||
Protection from financial risks[6,11] | Demographic characteristics | ||
Economic features | |||
Consumptions and healthcare costs | |||
Resource generation[6,11,31] | Health information system | [6,30,32] | |
Human resources | [6,30,32,34] | ||
Medicine and Medical supplies | [6,32] | ||
Growth and Learning | Collecting and using knowledge | [6] | |
Use of data audit and feedback processes | [33] | ||
Innovation adoption | |||
Training and continuing education for workforce | |||
Service delivery[6,31,32,34] | Adult Health Services (AHS) | [32] | |
Child Health Services (CHS) | |||
Antenatal Services[45] | |||
Outcomes | [14] | ||
Capacity for service provision | [34] | ||
Fairness in healthcare services delivery | [6] | ||
Continuity | [50] | ||
Coordination | [13,30,50] | ||
Comprehensiveness | Service available | [30,50] | |
Service provided | |||
Quality[10,11,13,17,31,33,51] | Quality of care (Clinical quality) | [11,33,61] | |
Management quality | [33] | ||
Wastage/errors | [51] | ||
Effectiveness of health services | [10,11,13,17,30,31,48,49] | ||
Safety | [10,13,17,30,31] | ||
Patient and community[34] | Patient/family satisfaction | [11,13] | |
Family-centeredness | [50] | ||
Community orientation | [50] | ||
Community support | [33] | ||
Responsiveness/patient centeredness[10,11,31,47] | Autonomy | [47] | |
Attention | |||
Communication | |||
Amenities | |||
Choice | |||
Confidentiality | |||
Respect | |||
Responsiveness to people’s non-medical expectation | [31] | ||
Appropriateness[30] | Adults receiving recommended screening and preventive care | [51] | |
Children receiving recommended screening and preventive care | |||
Others | |||
Access[10,11,13,17,31,33,48,51,61] | Equitable access to healthcare services | Financial factors | [6] |
Geographical factors | |||
Individual factors | |||
Structural factors | |||
Financial access | [33] | ||
Information access | |||
Linguistic access | |||
Physical access (Structural) | |||
Service availability/allocation | |||
Rural public health system coverage | [49] | ||
Equality of rural public health services | |||
Cultural competence | [50] | ||
Acceptability | [51] | ||
Efficiency/Utilization[11,13,30,33,48,51,61] | Administrative efficiency | [11] | |
Costs and productivity | |||
Adequacy of funding | |||
Direct inputs | [52] | ||
Direct output | |||
Contextual factors | |||
Patient or procedure volume per time period | [33] | ||
Patient or procedure volume-general | |||
Patient or procedure volume relative to capacity | |||
Patient or procedure volume relative to population | |||
Patient or procedure volume relative to population health characteristics | |||
Patient or procedure volume relative to the need of the patient | |||
Service usage relative to income group | |||
Cost to service ratios | |||
Staff to service ratios | |||
Additional costs | [51] | ||
Health status and community[11,30,31,61] | Improving the health of the population | [31,48] | |
Healthy lives | [51] | ||
Demographic and socio-economic factors | [31] | ||
Determinants of health | [31] |