Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2020 Dec 7.
Published in final edited form as: Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2019 Mar 26;161(1):28–35. doi: 10.1177/0194599819835178

Table I.

Studies Included in the Review.

Study Year Country Tinnitus Population Studied Instrument Patients with Tinnitus, n Men, % Mean Age or Range, y Depression Prevalence, % Quality Score
Adoga7 2008 Nigeria All tinnitus patients who presented to ENT clinic. HADS 92 45.7 36.0 17.4 4
Andersson14 2009 Sweden Cochlear implant recipients who reported tinnitus HADS 107 38.7 54.4 5.6 3
Barros Suzuki15 2016 Brazil Patients with tinnitus complaints for > 1 y without improvement with drug therapies and no tinnitus treatment for at least 3 mo HADS 10 50 41–78 10.0 3
Bartels16 2008 Netherlands Consecutive patients with chronic tinnitus seen at ENT clinic HADS ≥8 265 69.8 55.4 49.1 4
Belli8 2008 Turkey Patients with tinnitus symptoms for at least 1 mo with no drug therapies for 3 mo prior to the study SCI for DSM-III 85 45.6 38.4 5.6 4
Carlsson17 2015 Sweden Patients with severe to profound hearing impairment who reported tinnitus HADS ≥8 704 51 68.0 24.6 3
Crocetti18 2009 Italy Patients with idiopathic tinnitus for at least 6 mo (exclusion criteria: Meniere’s disease and chronic pain) BDI 108 66.7 48.0 13.0 4
Das19 2012 USA Patients with nonpulsatile tinnitus of at least 6 mo (exclusion criteria: active diagnosis of any acute or chronic brain-related neurologic condition) PHQ-9 ≥6 37 54 50.0 24.3 2
Fernandes20 2013 Brazil Patients with orofacial pain and self-reported tinnitus RDC/TMD 129 17.9 37.7 68.2 3
Folmer21 2008 USA Consecutive patients with chronic tinnitus presenting to ENT clinic for initial appointment aBDI 196 68.4 52.1 49.0 4
Gomaa22 2014 Egypt Patients with subjective tinnitus associated with hearing loss presenting to ENT clinic DASS 100 40 20–60 84 4
Granjeiro23 2013 Brazil Patients with tinnitus and normal hearing (exclusion criteria: drug treatment for tinnitus in past 6 mo; tinnitus <6 mo; history of acoustic trauma, vascular disease, ear surgery, vestibular disorders, head trauma, and neurologic diseases; recent intake of ototoxic drugs and chemo-/radiotherapy). BDI 68 45.6 36.8 66.2 3
Hilgenberg24 2012 Brazil Patients with tinnitus receiving regular dental care (exclusion criteria: Ménière’s disease, history of noise exposure or ear surgery or infections; frequent use of headphones; abuse of ototoxic medication or substances, including fluoxetine and alcohol; and systemic diseases [eg, diabetes, hypertension] beyond control) RDC/TMD 100 16 39.2 70.0 3
Jacques25 2013 Belgium Patients with chronic tinnitus consulting an audiophonology center. Clinical diagnosis of MDD (exact criteria unclear) 80 28.8 2
Langguth26 2007 Germany Consecutive patients presenting to tinnitus clinic for tinnitus as their primary complaint BDI ≥10 72 69.4 49.3 55.6 3
Meyer27 2014 Switzerland Chronic tinnitus patients volunteering for EEG study BDI 24 54.2 39.8 50.0 4
Michikawa28 2010 Japan Patients who self-reported tinnitus in the past year in a community-based cross-sectional study Self-report questiona 243 44.2 >65 33.7 2
Milhomem Rocha29 2015 Brazil Concomitant tinnitus and musical hallucinations SCID 16 12.5 61.4 68.8 3
Nondahl30 2011 USA Patients who self-reported tinnitus in the past year from the Beaver Dam Offspring Study, an epidemiologic cohort study of aging CES-D ≥ 16 345 51.3 50.8 24.6 4
Ooms11 2011 Belgium Consecutive tinnitus patients seen at ENT clinic BDI-II 136 64.7 49.1 33.1 4
Robinson31 2008 USA Patients with self-reported tinnitus distress volunteering for cognitive-behavior therapy trial (exclusion criterion: inability to participate in group) HRSD 65 52 55 24.6 4
Salonen32 2007 Finland Subjects who responded to survey on hearing loss and reported tinnitus with or without annoyance aBDI 343 41.2 70–85 19.0 3
Seo33 2016 Korea Subjects who were part of KNHANES and reported experiencing tinnitus in the past year Self-report questionb 3949 48.3 18.2 2
Shargorodsky34 2010 USA Subjects who were part of NHANES and reported experiencing tinnitus in the past year. WHO WMH-CIDI 2265 20–39 7.9 4
Sireci35 2012 Italy Patients with tinnitus referred to audiology clinic SCL 90-R 191 58.1 48.6 33.0 4
Trevis36 2016 Australia Patients who self-identified as experiencing constant tinnitus for at least 3 mo BDI-II 26 58 40.3 42.3 4
Vtillmann37 2013 Germany Patients with chronic tinnitus responding to mailed questionnaires HADS≥8 118 77.1 55.6 41.5 3
Zirke38 2013 Germany Patients with tinnitus for at least 3 mo admitted to tinnitus center CIDI 100 45 49.6 37.0 2

Abbreviations: aBDI, abbreviated Beck Depression Inventory; (0–4, no or minimal depression; 5–7, mild depression; 8–15, moderate depression; and ≥16, severe depression); BDI, Beck Depression Inventory; CES-D, Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale; CIDI, Composite International Diagnostic Interview (evaluated per criteria of the International Classification of Diseases, Tenth Revision and Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition); DASS, Depression, Anxiety and Stress Scale; DSM-III, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Third Edition; EEG, electroencephalogram; ENT, ear, nose, and throat; HADS, Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (unless otherwise stated, >10); HRSD, Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression; KNHANES, Korea National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey; MDD, major depressive disorder; NHANES, National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey; PHQ-9, Patient Health Questionnaire-9; RDC/TMD, Research Diagnostic Criteria for Temporomandibular Disorders; SCI, Structured Clinical Interview; SCL 90-R, Symptom Checklist-90 R; WHO WMH-CIDI, World Health Organization World Mental Health Composite International Diagnostic Interview.

a

Depression was evaluated with the question “Do you feel sad, depressed, or miserable?”

b

Depression was evaluated with the question “Have you experienced a depressed mood for 2 or more continuous weeks during the previous year?”