Table 1.
The performance of the previous studies on the prediction of MW generation
Author(s) | Province(s)/Country | Methods | Best Model Performance (R, R2) |
---|---|---|---|
Bdour et al. [9] | Irbid, Jordan | MLR | R2 = 0.918 |
Sabour et al. [10] | Gilan, Iran | Linear Regression | Not available |
Jahandideh et al. [11] | Fars, Iran | MLR, ANN | R2 = 0.990 (ANN) |
Eleyan et al. [12] | Jenin, Palestine | System Dynamics Models | Not available |
Idowu et al. [13] | Lagos, Nigeria | MLR Models | R2 = 0.998 |
Karpušenkaite et al. [14] | Lithuania | ANN, MLR, SVM, and different non-parametric regression methods |
R2 = 0.905 (with GANPR using regional dataset) R2 = 0.986 (with SSNPR using long annual dataset) |
Tesfahun et al. [15] | Ethiopian | Mathematical predictive models from the available literatures. |
R2 = 0.965 (with the number of inpatients) R2 = 0.424 (with the number of outpatients) |
Al-Khatib et al. [16] | Nablus, Palestine | MLR | R2 = 0.984 |
Chauhan and Singh [17] | Uttarakhand, India | ARIMA models | R2 = 0.832 with ARMA(1,1) model |
Minoglou and Komilis [18] | 41 Countries | MLR and Principal Component Analysis (PCA) | R2 = 0.8473 |
Adamović et al. [19] |
European countries |
General Regression Neural Network (GRNNs) Models |
R2 = 0.999 (for the prediction of chemical hazardous waste) R2 = 0.975 (for healthcare and biological hazardous waste) |
Karpušenkaitė et al. [20] | Lithuania | Time Series Moving Average, Time Series Holt’s Exponential Smoothing, Hybrid Model | Not available |
Thakur and Ramesh [21] | Uttarakhand, India |
MLR, ANN, and Polynomial Regression |
R2 = 0.954 (ANN for total waste) |
Golbaz et al. [22] | Karaj, Iran | MLR and several Neuron and Kernel based machine earning methods |
R2 = 0.82 – 0.86 (Kernel-based models) R2 = 0.68 – 0.74 (Neuron-based models) |
Hao et al. [23] | Shanghai, China | GM (1,1), Triple Exponential Smoothing (TES), Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO) Optimized Back Propagation (BP) Neural Network, and Hybrid Model | Not available |
Çetinkaya et al. [24] | Aksaray, Turkey | MLR | R2 = 0.979 |
*SSNPR: Smoothing splines non-parametric regression
*GANPR: Generalized additive non-parametric regression