Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2020 Dec 8.
Published in final edited form as: Med Phys. 2020 Aug 30;47(10):4971–4982. doi: 10.1002/mp.14429

Table 1.

(a) Dice Similarity Coefficient (DSC) and (b) Mean Surface Distance (MSD) between different network sizes of DenseUnet and PlainUnet on the test set. K is the growth rate of Densely Connected Block in DenseUnet, and f is the filter number of the first layer in PlainUnet. DenseUnet (k=32) runs faster than 100× larger PlainUnet (f=64) but still has comparable performance, showing the advanced densely connections help in overall performance. DenseUnet (k=48) gains the best performance while still maintains a fast run time. Best performances are highlighted in bold.

(a)
DenseUnet
Liver Pancreas Right Kidney Left Kidney Stomach Duodenum Small Intestine Spinal Cord Vertebral Body Spleen Mean Parameter Number Runtime(s)
k24 0.956±0.013 0.791±0.082 0.947±0.006 0.941±0.013 0.868±0.048 0.686±0.083 0.780±0.135 0.873±0.028 0.834±0.037 0.931±0.030 0.861±0.084 1.55M 13.179
k32 0.955±0.011 0.772±0.107 0.939±0.012 0.941±0.011 0.871±0.052 0.696±0.093 0.789±0.105 0.884±0.019 0.887±0.018 0.936±0.021 0.867±0.083 2.74M 13.977
k48 0.960±0.009 0.828±0.074 0.940±0.009 0.951±0.008 0.889±0.046 0.732±0.076 0.790±0.103 0.866±0.028 0.889±0.017 0.934±0.018 0.878±0.071 6.12M 18.052
k64 0.959±0.012 0.799±0.086 0.952±0.008 0.950±0.009 0.889±0.046 0.708±0.091 0.796±0.107 0.886±0.024 0.882±0.026 0.929±0.025 0.875±0.079 10.83M 21.040
PlainUnet
f64 0.957±0.012 0.740±0.131 0.943±0.010 0.943±0.012 0.870±0.045 0.695±0.075 0.792±0.098 0.888±0.024 0.884±0.016 0.908±0.037 0.862±0.086 229M 15.903
f80 0.953±0.013 0.774±0.106 0.945±0.007 0.943±0.013 0.851±0.055 0.711±0.072 0.765±0.106 0.853±0.028 0.875±0.025 0.901±0.043 0.857±0.080 358M 30.623
f96 0.953±0.009 0.793±0.073 0.938±0.016 0.933±0.023 0.861±0.051 0.717±0.077 0.766±0.132 0.876±0.020 0.884±0.017 0.927±0.025 0.865±0.077 515M 38.859
(b)
DenseUnet
Liver Pancreas Right Kidney Left Kidney Stomach Duodenum Small Intestine Spinal Cord Vertebral Body Spleen Mean Parameter Number Runtime (s)
k24 1.329±0.433 2.750±1.319 0.800±0.181 0.973±0.578 3.326±1.546 4.315±1.457 4.177±3.421 0.795±0.143 1.655±0.359 1.273±0.842 2.139±1.314 1.55M 13.179
k32 1.266±0.233 3.006±1.805 1.398±0.999 1.379±0.972 2.481±1.603 4.249±2.043 4.871±3.331 1.350±1.049 1.026±0.148 1.578±1.117 2.260±1.292 2.74M 13.977
k48 1.188±0.269 2.270±1.167 1.212±0.893 0.934±0.493 2.732±1.241 2.931±1.295 5.081±3.932 0.875±0.219 1.097±0.200 1.180±0.632 1.950±1.269 6.12M 18.052
k64 1.218±0.367 3.324±2.849 0.738±0.165 0.743±0.205 2.367±0.976 4.275±1.832 4.604±3.441 0.738±0.110 1.461±1.523 1.433±0.978 2.090±1.405 10.83M 21.040
PlainUnet
f64 1.318±0.367 2.664±1.395 1.212±0.796 1.121±0.669 2.799±1.100 4.352±2.010 4.760±2.888 0.811±0.264 1.089±0.219 1.666±1.042 2.179±1.346 229M 15.903
f80 1.459±0.376 2.603±1.201 1.069±0.584 1.332±0.962 3.070±1.225 3.708±1.607 5.161±3.245 0.977±0.184 1.257±0.271 2.041±1.487 2.268±1.300 358M 30.623
f96 1.470±0.283 2.792±1.307 2.576±1.865 1.822±1.263 3.130±0.941 4.332±1.767 5.122±4.012 1.211±0.488 1.743±1.340 1.667±0.859 2.586±1.228 515M 38.859