Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2020 Dec 8.
Published in final edited form as: Med Phys. 2020 Aug 30;47(10):4971–4982. doi: 10.1002/mp.14429

Table 3.

(a) Dice Similarity Coefficient (DSC) and (b) Mean Surface Distance (MSD) (in units of mm) for progressively adding different training and testing settings: projective deformation (PD), deep-supervised training (DS), multi-view training (MTT), and multi-view inference (MTI). “*” indicates significant difference (p < 0.05/8 = 6.25e-3 considering Bonferroni correction) when comparing each of the other scenarios to the baseline model - the non-normalized DenseUnet (k=48) network. Best performances are highlighted in bold.

(a)
Liver Pancreas Right Kidney Left Kidney Stomach Duodenum Small Intestine Spinal Cord Vertebral Body Spleen Mean P-value Time (s)
Baseline 0.961±0.008 0.860±0.042 0.954±0.006 0.952±0.009 0.907±0.024 0.766±0.066 0.839±0.085 0.898±0.021 0.886±0.015 0.944±0.013 0.897±0.059 - 8.31
+PD 0.962±0.008 0.864±0.034 0.953±0.007 0.952±0.007 0.913±0.027 0.775±0.055 0.846±0.091 0.898±0.024 0.895±0.016 0.944±0.011 0.900±0.056 7.377e-02 8.37
+PD+DS 0.960±0.010 0.869±0.038 0.953±0.007 0.952±0.008 0.916±0.019 0.771±0.074 0.850±0.077 0.897±0.022 0.893±0.014 0.945±0.013 0.901±0.056 1.811e-02 8.32
+PD+DS +MTT 0.961±0.011 0.870±0.042 0.954±0.007 0.954±0.009 0.913±0.022 0.782±0.069 0.860±0.063 0.895±0.017 0.895±0.011 0.945±0.014 0.903±0.053* 4.604e-03 8.33
+PD+DS +MTT+MTI 0.963±0.010 0.880±0.035 0.954±0.007 0.954±0.008 0.923±0.020 0.801±0.065 0.870±0.060 0.904±0.014 0.900±0.010 0.946±0.013 0.909±0.048* 7.801e-06 12.25
(b)
Liver Pancreas Right Kidney Left Kidney Stomach Duodenum Small Intestine Spinal Cord Vertebral Body Spleen Mean P-value Time (s)
Baseline 1.135±0.204 1.307±0.472 0.693±0.083 0.812±0.377 1.905±0.698 2.189±0.865 2.771±2.608 0.678±0.098 0.994±0.200 1.047±0.436 1.353±0.669 - 8.31
+PD 1.117±0.248 1.215±0.303 0.685±0.118 0.693±0.137 1.736±0.590 2.128±0.759 2.593±2.942 0.663±0.102 0.938±0.196 1.063±0.645 1.283±0.627 6.927e-02 8.37
+PD+DS 1.194±0.296 1.169±0.368 0.681±0.103 0.734±0.180 1.618±0.429 2.262±1.007 2.744±2.860 0.667±0.088 0.948±0.119 1.221±0.869 1.324±0.661 1.654e-02 8.32
+PD+DS +MTT 1.137±0.303 1.167±0.363 0.657±0.084 0.655±0.094 1.618±0.505 2.254±0.924 1.959±1.709 0.675±0.076 0.939±0.106 1.027±0.505 1.209±0.532* 2.939e-03 8.33
+PD+DS +MTT+MTI 1.072±0.268 1.027±0.273 0.655±0.087 0.645±0.090 1.338±0.308 1.831±0.873 1.960±2.671 0.630±0.070 0.892±0.098 0.941±0.321 1.099±0.451* 2.493e-06 12.25