Table 1.
Characteristics of included studies
Study | Geographic scope | Temporal scope | Outcome measures | Units of analysis | Convergence concept(s) included | Dispersion measure | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Stańczyk,34 2016 | 260 regions (NUTS 2) in 28 EU Member States (excluding outlier regions) | 2002–12 | LEB | NUTS 2 regions | Beta convergence | Not applicable | Convergence |
Maynou and Saez,31 2016 | 271 regions (NUTS 2) in 27 EU Member States (excluding Croatia) | 1995–2011 | LEB and all-cause SMR | NUTS 2 regions | Beta and sigma convergence | Coefficient of variation | Both beta convergence analyses: convergence Both sigma convergence analyses: divergence |
Maynou et al.,29 2015 | 271 regions (NUTS 2) in 27 EU Member States (excluding Croatia) | 1995–2007 | LEB | NUTS 2 regions | Beta and sigma convergence | Coefficient of variation | Convergence |
Richardson et al.,32 2014 | 129 mainland regions (NUTS 2) in 13 EU Member States (Austria, Belgium, Spain, Finland, France, Italy, Portugal, Sweden, Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Lithuania and Poland) | 1991–2008 | Sex-specific LEB | Deciles based on life expectancy and income | Sigma convergence | Interdecile range | Persistence |
Jaworska,28 2014 | 265 regions (NUTS 2) in 28 EU Member States | 2002–12 | LEB | NUTS 2 regions | Beta convergence | Not applicable | Convergence |
Marmot et al.,30 2013 | 28 EU Member States and 268 EU regions (NUTS 2) | 2002–09, 2000–10 | Sex-specific LEB | Member States, NUTS 2 regions | Sigma convergence | Range, ratio and Gini coefficient | Member States (2000–10), female LEB, Gini coefficient: convergence Other 13 analyses show persistence |
Spinakis et al.,33 2011 | 27 EU Member States (excluding Croatia) | 1997–2008 | All-cause SMR for under 64 years of age | Member States | Sigma convergence | Interquartile and interdecile range, coefficient of variation, standard deviation of logs, Gini coefficient, Theil coefficient and Atkinson coefficient | Divergence in all 10 analyses |
EU, European Union; LEB, life expectancy at birth; NUTS, nomenclature of territorial units for statistics; SMR, age- and sex-standardized mortality rate.