Skip to main content
. 2020 Mar 24;30(6):1108–1115. doi: 10.1093/eurpub/ckaa038

Table 1.

Characteristics of included studies

Study Geographic scope Temporal scope Outcome measures Units of analysis Convergence concept(s) included Dispersion measure Results
Stańczyk,34 2016 260 regions (NUTS 2) in 28 EU Member States (excluding outlier regions) 2002–12 LEB NUTS 2 regions Beta convergence Not applicable Convergence
Maynou and Saez,31 2016 271 regions (NUTS 2) in 27 EU Member States (excluding Croatia) 1995–2011 LEB and all-cause SMR NUTS 2 regions Beta and sigma convergence Coefficient of variation Both beta convergence analyses: convergence Both sigma convergence analyses: divergence
Maynou et al.,29 2015 271 regions (NUTS 2) in 27 EU Member States (excluding Croatia) 1995–2007 LEB NUTS 2 regions Beta and sigma convergence Coefficient of variation Convergence
Richardson et al.,32 2014 129 mainland regions (NUTS 2) in 13 EU Member States (Austria, Belgium, Spain, Finland, France, Italy, Portugal, Sweden, Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Lithuania and Poland) 1991–2008 Sex-specific LEB Deciles based on life expectancy and income Sigma convergence Interdecile range Persistence
Jaworska,28 2014 265 regions (NUTS 2) in 28 EU Member States 2002–12 LEB NUTS 2 regions Beta convergence Not applicable Convergence
Marmot et al.,30 2013 28 EU Member States and 268 EU regions (NUTS 2) 2002–09, 2000–10 Sex-specific LEB Member States, NUTS 2 regions Sigma convergence Range, ratio and Gini coefficient Member States (2000–10), female LEB, Gini coefficient: convergence Other 13 analyses show persistence
Spinakis et al.,33 2011 27 EU Member States (excluding Croatia) 1997–2008 All-cause SMR for under 64 years of age Member States Sigma convergence Interquartile and interdecile range, coefficient of variation, standard deviation of logs, Gini coefficient, Theil coefficient and Atkinson coefficient Divergence in all 10 analyses

EU, European Union; LEB, life expectancy at birth; NUTS, nomenclature of territorial units for statistics; SMR, age- and sex-standardized mortality rate.