Table 4.
One-way sensitivity analysis results for extended time horizon
| Year | Strategy | Strategyindex | Cost | Incr costa | Effb | Incr effc | ICERd | NMBe | C/Ef | Dominance |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | Baseline(REP only) | 2 | 588.95 | 0 | 0.475 | 0 | 0 | 46911.05 | 1239.894737 | |
| 0 | REP+EF/IF | 1 | 625.9527273 | 37.00272727 | 0.466136364 | − 0.008863636 | − 4174.666667 | 45987.68364 | 1342.853242 | (Dominated) |
| 0 | REP+EF, addIF if needed | 0 | 627.3952381 | 38.4452381 | 0.539785714 | 0.064785714 | 593.4215362 | 53351.17619 | 1162.304265 | |
| 0 | REP+EF only | 3 | 637.5285714 | 10.13333333 | 0.484595238 | − 0.055190476 | − 183.6065574 | 47821.99524 | 1315.589839 | (Dominated) |
| 1 | Baseline(REP only) | 2 | 588.95 | 0 | 0.95 | 0 | 0 | 94411.05 | 619.9473684 | |
| 1 | REP+EF/IF | 1 | 625.9527273 | 37.00272727 | 0.935409091 | − 0.014590909 | − 2536.012461 | 92914.95636 | 669.175373 | (Dominated) |
| 1 | REP+EF, addIF if needed | 0 | 627.3952381 | 38.4452381 | 1.122357143 | 0.172357143 | 223.0556707 | 111608.319 | 558.9978574 | |
| 1 | REP+EF only | 3 | 637.5285714 | 10.13333333 | 0.956785714 | − 0.165571429 | − 61.20218579 | 95041.04286 | 666.3232549 | (Dominated) |
| 2 | Baseline(REP only) | 2 | 588.95 | 0 | 1.425 | 0 | 0 | 141911.05 | 413.2982456 | |
| 2 | REP+EF/IF | 1 | 625.9527273 | 37.00272727 | 1.404681818 | − 0.020318182 | − 1821.163311 | 139842.2291 | 445.618872 | (Dominated) |
| 2 | REP+EF, addIF if needed | 0 | 627.3952381 | 38.4452381 | 1.704928571 | 0.279928571 | 137.3394573 | 169865.4619 | 367.9891631 | |
| 2 | REP+EF only | 3 | 637.5285714 | 10.13333333 | 1.42897619 | − 0.275952381 | − 36.72131148 | 142260.0905 | 446.1435926 | (Dominated) |
| 3 | Baseline(REP only) | 2 | 588.95 | 0 | 1.9 | 0 | 0 | 189411.05 | 309.9736842 | |
| 3 | REP+EF/IF | 1 | 625.9527273 | 37.00272727 | 1.873954545 | − 0.026045455 | − 1420.69808 | 186769.5018 | 334.0277003 | (Dominated) |
| 3 | REP+EF, addIF if needed | 0 | 627.3952381 | 38.4452381 | 2.2875 | 0.3875 | 99.21351767 | 228122.6048 | 274.2711423 | |
| 3 | REP+EF only | 3 | 637.5285714 | 10.13333333 | 1.901166667 | − 0.386333333 | − 26.2295082 | 189479.1381 | 335.3354457 | (Dominated) |
| 4 | Baseline(REP only) | 2 | 588.95 | 0 | 2.375 | 0 | 0 | 236911.05 | 247.9789474 | |
| 4 | REP+EF/IF | 1 | 625.9527273 | 37.00272727 | 2.343227273 | − 0.031772727 | − 1164.606581 | 233696.7745 | 267.1327423 | (Dominated) |
| 4 | REP+EF, addIF if needed | 0 | 627.3952381 | 38.4452381 | 2.870071429 | 0.495071429 | 77.6559419 | 286379.7476 | 218.5991721 | |
| 4 | REP+EF only | 3 | 637.5285714 | 10.13333333 | 2.373357143 | − 0.496714286 | − 20.4007286 | 236698.1857 | 268.6188943 | (Dominated) |
| 5 | Baseline(REP only) | 2 | 588.95 | 0 | 2.85 | 0 | 0 | 284411.05 | 206.6491228 | |
| 5 | REP+EF/IF | 1 | 625.9527273 | 37.00272727 | 2.8125 | − 0.0375 | − 986.7393939 | 280624.0473 | 222.5609697 | (Dominated) |
| 5 | REP+EF, addIF if needed | 0 | 627.3952381 | 38.4452381 | 3.452642857 | 0.602642857 | 63.79439769 | 344636.8905 | 181.7144906 | |
| 5 | REP+EF only | 3 | 637.5285714 | 10.13333333 | 2.845547619 | − 0.607095238 | − 16.69150522 | 283917.2333 | 224.0442462 | (Dominated) |
| 6 | Baseline(REP only) | 2 | 588.95 | 0 | 3.325 | 0 | 0 | 331911.05 | 177.1278195 | |
| 6 | REP+EF/IF | 1 | 625.9527273 | 37.00272727 | 3.281772727 | − 0.043227273 | − 856.0042061 | 327551.32 | 190.7361598 | (Dominated) |
| 6 | REP+EF, addIF if needed | 0 | 627.3952381 | 38.4452381 | 4.035214286 | 0.710214286 | 54.13188508 | 402894.0333 | 155.48003 | |
| 6 | REP+EF only | 3 | 637.5285714 | 10.13333333 | 3.317738095 | − 0.71747619 | − 14.12358134 | 331136.281 | 192.1575945 | (Dominated) |
| 7 | Baseline(REP only) | 2 | 588.95 | 0 | 3.8 | 0 | 0 | 379411.05 | 154.9868421 | |
| 7 | REP+EF/IF | 1 | 625.9527273 | 37.00272727 | 3.751045455 | − 0.048954545 | − 755.8588672 | 374478.5927 | 166.8742048 | (Dominated) |
| 7 | REP+EF, addIF if needed | 0 | 627.3952381 | 38.4452381 | 4.617785714 | 0.817785714 | 47.01138382 | 461151.1762 | 135.8649528 | |
| 7 | REP+EF only | 3 | 637.5285714 | 10.13333333 | 3.789928571 | − 0.827857143 | − 12.24043716 | 378355.3286 | 168.2165137 | (Dominated) |
| 8 | Baseline(REP only) | 2 | 588.95 | 0 | 4.275 | 0 | 0 | 426911.05 | 137.7660819 | |
| 8 | REP+EF/IF | 1 | 625.9527273 | 37.00272727 | 4.220318182 | − 0.054681818 | − 676.6916043 | 421405.8655 | 148.3188471 | (Dominated) |
| 8 | REP+EF, addIF if needed | 0 | 627.3952381 | 38.4452381 | 5.200357143 | 0.925357143 | 41.54637849 | 519408.319 | 120.6446444 | |
| 8 | REP+EF only | 3 | 637.5285714 | 10.13333333 | 4.262119048 | − 0.938238095 | − 10.80038573 | 425574.3762 | 149.5801887 | (Dominated) |
| 9 | Baseline(REP only) | 2 | 588.95 | 0 | 4.75 | 0 | 0 | 474411.05 | 123.9894737 | |
| 9 | REP+EF/IF | 1 | 625.9527273 | 37.00272727 | 4.689590909 | − 0.060409091 | − 612.5357412 | 468333.1382 | 133.477043 | (Dominated) |
| 9 | REP+EF, addIF if needed | 0 | 627.3952381 | 38.4452381 | 5.782928571 | 1.032928571 | 37.21964825 | 577665.4619 | 108.4909195 | |
| 9 | REP+EF only | 3 | 637.5285714 | 10.13333333 | 4.734309524 | − 1.048619048 | − 9.66350302 | 472793.4238 | 134.6613626 | (Dominated) |
| 10 | Baseline(REP only) | 2 | 588.95 | 0 | 5.225 | 0 | 0 | 521911.05 | 112.7177033 | |
| 10 | REP+EF/IF | 1 | 625.9527273 | 37.00272727 | 5.158863636 | − 0.066136364 | − 559.4914089 | 515260.4109 | 121.3353892 | (Dominated) |
| 10 | REP+EF, addIF if needed | 0 | 627.3952381 | 38.4452381 | 6.3655 | 1.1405 | 33.70910837 | 635922.6048 | 98.56181574 | |
| 10 | REP+EF only | 3 | 637.5285714 | 10.13333333 | 5.2065 | − 1.159 | − 8.743169399 | 520012.4714 | 122.4485876 | (Dominated) |
aIncremental cost
bEffectiveness
cIncremental effectiveness
dIncremental cost-effectiveness ratio
eNet monetary benefit
fCost-effectiveness