Skip to main content
. 2020 Dec 16;156(3):247–254. doi: 10.1001/jamasurg.2020.5670

Table 5. Reasons Given by Academic Surgeons for Considering Leaving Academic Practice Within the Next 2 Years and by Private Practice Surgeons for Not Pursuing a Primarily Academic Career Among Actively Practicing US Fellows of the American College of Surgeons (2018)a.

Reason Respondents, No./total No. (%)
Academic surgeons (n = 376)b Private practice surgeons (n = 1309)b
Personal time requirements 230/386 (60) 346/1328 (26)
Overall stress 189/380 (50) 267/1318 (20)
Family responsibilities 166/377 (44) 367/1320 (28)
Changing career interests 122/373 (33) 177/1292 (14)
Inadequate career advancement 112/369 (30) 262/1309 (20)
Sense of isolation 100/363 (28) 110/1278 (9)
Inadequate reimbursement 101/374 (27) 406/1328 (31)
Inadequate mentoring 90/366 (24) 184/1285 (14)
Harassment 72/366 (20) 189/1275 (15)
Research responsibilities 64/369 (17) 466/1306 (36)
Inadequate job opportunities 63/369 (17) 194/1302 (23)
Uncertainty of grant funding 55/359 (15) 264/1269 (21)
Malpractice concerns 46/368 (12) 73/1305 (6)
Teaching responsibilities 36/375 (10) 210/1325 (16)
Inadequate case diversity 27/364 (8) 202/1308 (16)
a

Results weighted to account for potential nonresponse bias. Only academic surgeons considering leaving surgery within the next 2 years are included. All surgeons considered as primarily private practice are included. Questions were asked in a 5-point Likert scale with responses of 4 (agree) and 5 (strongly agree) considered positive responses. P values were not calculated as the question stem differed between academic and private practice surgeons.

b

Practice type was reported by respondents (“Are you currently primarily in a private practice setting?” and “Do you currently hold a medical school faculty appointment?”); respondents who answered no to both questions were excluded. Respondents who answered yes to both questions were considered to be in a private practice setting.