Skip to main content
. 2020 Dec 17;10:22169. doi: 10.1038/s41598-020-79030-6

Table 1.

Ranking of candidate reference genes.

geNorm
Ranking
Developmental stage Tissue
Gene name M-value Gene name M-value
1 αTUB 0.300 ACT 0.892
2 GAPDH 0.307 UBC 0.991
3 HSP70 0.316 αTUB 1.018
4 ACT 0.329 HSP70 1.038
5 UBC 0.371 EF1α 1.043
6 RPS18 0.387 RPS18 1.123
7 ATPase 0.408 GAPDH 1.144
8 EF1α 0.453 ATPase 1.599
9 HSP60 0.551 HSP60 1.630
10 GST 0.717 GST 1.709
BestKeeper
Ranking
Developmental stage Tissue
Gene name SD [r] Gene name SD [r]
1 GAPDH 0.37 0.977 RPS18 0.56 0.975
2 αTUB 0.40 0.984 GAPDH 0.74 0.959
3 ACT 0.43 0.999 ATPase 0.91 0.889
4 HSP70 0.45 0.996 UBC 0.96 0.981
5 UBC 0.31 0.893 ACT 0.99 0.995
6 EF1α 0.47 0.898 EF1α 1.03 0.982
7 RPS18 1.24 0.977 HSP70 1.14 0.984
8 ATPase 0.51 0.043 αTUB 1.19 0.988
9 GST 0.59 0.598 HSP60 1.98 0.987
10 HSP60 0.66 0.772 GST 1.52 0.837
Normfinder
Ranking
Developmental stage Tissue
Gene name Stability Value Gene name Stability Value
1 GAPDH 0.036 EF1α 0.145
2 αTUB 0.038 ACT 0.166
3 HSP70 0.088 HSP70 0.190
4 ACT 0.145 UBC 0.206
5 UBC 0.230 αTUB 0.212
6 RPS18 0.231 RPS18 0.492
7 EF1α 0.236 GAPDH 0.598
8 ATPase 0.238 ATPase 0.813
9 HSP60 0.258 HSP60 0.816
10 GST 0.491 GST 1.235
Comparative ΔCt
Ranking
Developmental stage Tissue
Gene name Stability Value Gene name Stability Value
1 ACT 0.46 ACT 0.90
2 HSP70 0.46 UBC 1.00
3 αTUB 0.46 αTUB 1.02
4 GAPDH 0.47 HSP70 1.04
5 UBC 0.57 EF1α 1.04
6 EF1α 0.57 RPS18 1.13
7 HSP60 0.70 GAPDH 1.15
8 GST 0.87 ATPase 1.60
9 ATPase 1.08 HSP60 1.67
10 RPS18 1.26 GST 1.71

The bold indicates the gene expression is unstable under specific experimental conditions.