Table 3.
Dataset | Method | Prec. | Rec. | Dice |
---|---|---|---|---|
Synthetic | DeepVesselNet-FCN | 99.84 | 99.87 | 99.86 |
DeepVesselNet-VNet | 99.54 | 99.59 | 99.56 | |
DeepVesselNet-UNet | 99.48 | 99.42 | 99.45 | |
VNet | 99.48 | 99.50 | 99.49 | |
UNet | 99.57 | 99.52 | 99.55 | |
Schneider et al. | 99.47 | 99.56 | 99.52 | |
TOF MRA | DeepVesselNet-FCN (finetuned) | 86.44 | 86.93 | 86.68 |
DeepVesselNet-FCN (pretrained) | 82.76 | 80.25 | 81.48 | |
DeepVesselNet-VNet (finetuned) | 85.00 | 83.51 | 84.25 | |
DeepVesselNet-VNet (pretrained) | 83.32 | 77.12 | 80.10 | |
DeepVesselNet-UNet (finetuned) | 83.56 | 85.18 | 84.36 | |
DeepVesselNet-UNet (pretrained) | 83.48 | 79.27 | 81.32 | |
VNet (finetuned) | 84.34 | 85.62 | 84.97 | |
VNet (pretrained) | 82.41 | 75.82 | 78.98 | |
UNet (finetuned) | 84.02 | 85.35 | 84.68 | |
UNet (pretrained) | 83.16 | 80.23 | 81.67 | |
Schneider et al. | 84.81 | 82.15 | 83.46 | |
Forkert et al. | 84.99 | 73.00 | 78.57 | |
μCTA | DeepVesselNet-FCN | 96.72 | 95.82 | 96.27 |
DeepVesselNet-VNet | 95.83 | 96.18 | 96.01 | |
DeepVesselNet-UNet | 95.85 | 96.06 | 95.95 | |
VNet | 95.25 | 95.84 | 95.55 | |
UNet | 95.27 | 95.71 | 95.49 | |
Schneider et al. | 95.15 | 91.51 | 93.30 |
TOF MRA are evaluated within the brain region only.
Pretrained results refers to the scores we obtained on the test set after pretraining, and finetuned results are scores after finetuning with annotated data available for TOF-MRA.
Best performing method in each metric are show in bold.