Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2021 Oct 21.
Published in final edited form as: ACS Chem Neurosci. 2020 Sep 30;11(20):3455–3463. doi: 10.1021/acschemneuro.0c00551

Table 2.

Calculated binding free energies (kcal/mol) compared to the corresponding experimental binding free energies (kcal/mol, derived from the experimental Ki shown in Figure 1 or 2).

Liganda ΔG(CB1R) ΔG(CB2R) ΔG(CB1R)-ΔG(CB2R)
ΔGPBb ΔGcorrc ΔGexpd ΔGPBb ΔGcorrc ΔGexpd ΔΔGcorrc,e ΔΔGexpf
ACEA52 −39.07 −12.08 −12.15 −18.19 −7.60 −7.82 −4.98 −4.33
O-186027 −38.44 −11.97 −11.88 −19.30 −7.96 −6.86 −4.54 −5.02
ACPA53 −36.78 −11.67 −11.88 −24.95 −9.79 −8.44 −2.68 −3.45
O-181227 −35.54 −11.44 −11.62 −18.06 −7.56 −7.43 −4.12 −4.20
AM88153 −35.45 −11.43 −11.36 −26.78 −10.38 −9.64 −1.87 −1.72
AM88354 −35.10 −11.36 −10.99 −25.48 −9.96 −9.12 −2.11 −1.86
VJ-11528 −21.05 −8.82 −7.52 −25.19 −9.86 −8.60 1.39 1.08
R-Methanandamide53 −29.66 −10.38 −10.57 −22.18 −8.89 −8.36 −1.57 −2.21
2-AG53 −29.28 −10.31 −9.93 −24.23 −9.55 −9.39 −0.95 −0.54
Anandamide53 −27.69 −10.02 −9.90 −19.37 −7.98 −7.84 −1.79 −2.06
AM117455 −25.09 −9.55 −9.53 −16.34 −7.00 −7.48 −1.89 −2.05
O-181127 −24.13 −9.38 −9.52 −19.74 −8.10 −8.37 −0.79 −1.16
S-Methanandamide25 −23.83 −9.32 −9.28 −19.40 −7.99 −6.98 −0.80 −2.30
PNR-4-2028 −25.79 −9.67 −9.33 −26.52 −10.29 −12.00 0.52 2.67
PNR-4-0428 −25.22 −9.57 −9.43 −25.84 −10.07 −10.89 0.49 1.46
PNR-4-0228 −27.64 −10.01 −9.80 −27.78 −10.70 −10.57 0.37 0.77
PNR-4-0528 −21.95 −8.98 −8.85 −24.10 −9.51 −9.83 0.88 0.98
PNR-4-9928 −25.28 −9.58 −9.54 −25.78 −10.06 −9.81 0.46 0.28
PNR-9-3328 −16.18 −7.93 −7.60 −23.26 −9.24 −9.55 2.13 1.95
PNR-4-0328 −28.42 −10.15 −9.63 −23.26 −9.24 −9.57 −0.98 −0.06
PNR-4-1528 −28.18 −10.11 −9.96 −20.72 −8.42 −9.53 −1.57 −0.43
PNR-4-1728 −16.52 −7.99 −8.26 −19.31 −7.96 −8.55 1.04 0.29
RMSD (kcal/mol) 0.35 0.75 0.75
a

The subscript after the ligand name refers to the reference for the experimental Ki (shown in Figure 1 or 2) used to derive the experimental binding free energy.

b

Calculated binding free energies obtained from the MM-PBSA calculations without any empirical correction.

c

Calculated binding free energies after empirical correction using Eq. (1), (2), or (3).

d

The experimental binding free energy was converted from the experimental Ki using the well-known thermodynamic equation: ΔGexp = −RTln (Ki).

e

ΔΔGcorr is the corrected binding free energy difference (ΔG(CB1R) −ΔG(CB2R)).

f

ΔΔGexp = −RTln (Ki (CB1R)/Ki(CB2R)) = ΔGexp(CB1R) −ΔGexp(CB2R).