Skip to main content
. 2020 Nov 23;12(23):23450–23463. doi: 10.18632/aging.104086

Table 1. Quality assessment and baseline characteristics of the included studies.

Study and year Quality assessment Country Publishing language Sample size Males/Females Age Cerebrovascular disease, (%) Hypertension, (%) Dizziness or headache, (%)
Li,2020[8] ★★★★★★ China Chinese 80 40/40 3-90 14, (17.5) 12, (15.0)
Yuan,2020[9] ★★★★★ China Chinese 223 106/117 46.5±16.1 25, (11.2) 11, (4.9)
Wang,2020a[10] ★★★★ China Chinese 32 16/16 5, (15.6) 1, (3.1)
Zhang,2020a[11] ★★★★ China Chinese 61 36/25 3-85 15, (24.6) 9, (14.8)
Zuo,2020[12] ★★★★★ China Chinese 50 18/32 48.2±15.3 2, (4.0) 9, (18.0) 3, (6.0)
Wang,2020b[13] ★★★★ China Chinese 96 46/50 3, (3.1) 50, (52.1) 2, (2.1)
Lei,2020[14] ★★★★ China Chinese 51 25/16 26-82 1, (1.96) 9, (17.6) 1, (1.96)
Dong,2020[15] ★★★★★★ China Chinese 27 13/14 23-68 4, (14.8) 4, (14.8)
Zhao,2020[16] ★★★★ China Chinese 21 14/7 4-72 4, (19.0) 4, (19.0)
Tong,2020[17] ★★★ China Chinese 258 133/125 46.97±17.8 1, (0.39) 32, (12.4)
Suo,2020[18] ★★★★★ China Chinese 171 67/104 49±20 24, (14) 16, (9.4)
Zhong,2020[19] ★★★★ China Chinese 62 40/22 28-77 2, (3.2)
Xu,2020a[20] ★★★★★ China Chinese 155 87/68 41.99±15.40 5, (3.2)
Gong,2020[21] ★★★★★★ China Chinese 80 45/35 18-82 8, (10.0) 10, (8.0)
Chen,2020a[22] ★★★★★ China Chinese 67 20/47 11-85 12, (17.9)
Lu,2020[23] ★★★★★ China Chinese 50 28/22 50.4±16.8 8, (16)
Huang,2020a[24] ★★★★ China Chinese 35 19/16 12-74 1, (2.9) 3, (8.6)
Liang,2020a[25] ★★★ China Chinese 28 16/12 24-87 1, (3.6) 9, (32.1)
Zhuang,2020[26] ★★★★ China Chinese 26 18/8 3-79 4, (15.4) 6, (23.1)
Yang,2020[27] ★★★★★★ China English 149 81/68 45.11±13.35 0, (0) 13, (8.7)
Chen,2020b[28] ★★★★★★ China English 249 126/123 51±20.74 28, (11.2)
Liu,2020a[29] ★★★★★ China English 56 31/25 10, (17.9)
Lovell,2020[30] ★★★★★★★ British English 101 64/37 82.0±12.6 12, (11.9) 54, (53.5)
Huang,2020b[31] ★★★★★★★ China English 41 30/11 49.0±12.6 6, (14.6) 3, (7.9)
Chen,2020c[32] ★★★★★★★ China English 99 67/32 55.5±13.1 1, (1.0) 8, (8.1)
Zhou,2020a[33] ★★★★★★★★ China English 191 119/72 56.0±15.6 58, (30.3)
Goyal,2020[34] ★★★★ America English 393 238/155 62.2±18.6 197, (50.1)
Guan,2020[35] ★★★★★★★★ China English 1099 640/459 47.0±17.0 15, (1.4) 165, (15.0) 150, (13.6)
Chen,2020d[36] ★★★★★★ China English 203 108/95 20-91 43, (21.2) 9, (4.4) 14, (6.9)
Qian,2020[37] ★★★★ China English 91 37/54 5-96 15, (16.5) 7, (7.7)
Liu,2020b[38] ★★★★★★★ China English 137 61/76 20-83 13, (9.5) 13, (9.5)
Zhang,2020b[39] ★★★★★ China English 140 71/69 25-87 3, (2.1) 42, (30)
Zhou,2020b[40] ★★★★★★ China English 21 13/8 66.1±13.9 3, (14.3) 10, (47.6) 0, (0)
Xu,2020b[41] ★★★★★★★ China English 62 35/27 41.0±15.6 1, (1.6) 5, (8.1) 21, (33.9)
Chen,2020e[42] ★★★★★★ China English 274 171/103 62.0±19.3 4, (1.5) 93, (33.9) 52, (19.0)
Zheng,2020a[43] ★★★★★ China English 96 58/38 55.0±15.2 35,(36.5) 11, (11.5)
Liang,2020b[44] ★★★★★★★ China English 1590 904/674 48.9±16.3 30, (1.9) 269, (16.9) 205, (15.4)
Wang,2020c[45] ★★★★★★★ China English 138 75/63 56.0±19.3 7, (5.1) 43, (31.2) 21, (15.2)
Zheng,2020b[46] ★★★ China English 161 80/81 45±17.4 4, (2.5) 22, (13.7) 12, (7.5)
Wu,2020[47] ★★★★★★ China English 80 39/41 46.1±15.4 1, (1.3) 13, (16.3)
Wang,2020d[48] ★★★★ China English 26 11/15 42.0±14.7 5, (19.2) 1, (3.9)
Grasselli,2020[49] ★★★★★★★★ Italy English 1591 1304/287 63.0±10.4 509, (48.8)
Richardson,2020[50] ★★★★★★★★ America English 5700 3437/2263 0-107 3026, (53.1)
Wan,2020[51] ★★★★★ China English 135 72/63 47±14.1 13, (9.6) 34, (25.2)
Xu,2020c[52] ★★★★ China English 90 39/51 18-86 17, (18.9) 4, (4.4)
Wang,2020e[53] ★★★★★ China English 1012 524/488 16-89 46, (45.4) 152, (15)
Zhang,2020c[54] ★★★★ China English 645 328/326 46.65±13.82 100, (15.5) 67, (10.4)