Table 4.
Reference (Year of Publication) (Ref) |
N | Formula | T | Remission Criteria | R |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
O’Morain 1 (1984) [14] | 11 | E | 4 | H-B | 80% |
Giaffer 2 (1990) [108] | 14 | P | 4 | CDAI | 36% |
16 | E | 75% | |||
Malchow 1 (1990) [109] | 51 | P | 3–6 | CDAI | 41% |
Lochs 1 (1991) [110] | 52 | P | 4–6 | CDAI | 55% |
Rigaud 2 (1991) [111] | 15 | P | 4 | CDAI | 73% |
15 | E | 66% | |||
Park 2 (1991) [112] | 7 | P | 4 | Simple activity index | 73% |
7 | E | 69% | |||
Raouf 2 (1991) [113] | 11 | P | 3 | Simple activity index | 71% |
13 | E | 29% | |||
Lindor 1 (1992) [114] | 9 | E | 4 | CDAI | 33% |
González-Huix 1 (1993) [115] | 15 | P | 4 | Van Hess index | 80% |
Gorard 1 (1993) [116] | 22 | E | 4 | Simple activity index | 32% |
Royall 2 (1994) [117] | 19 | E | 3 | CDAI | 84% |
21 | O | 75% | |||
Mansfield 2 (1995) [118] | 22 | O | 4 | CDAI | 36% |
22 | E | 36% | |||
Verma 2 (2000) [119] | 11 | P | 4 | CDAI | 55% |
10 | E | 80% | |||
Sakurai (2002) [120] | 36 | P | 6 | CDAI | 70% |
Gassull 1 (2002) [121] | 43 | P | 4 | CDAI | 36% |
Guo (2013) [122] | 13 | P | 4 | CDAI | 85% |
Hu (2014) [67] | 59 | O | 12 | CDAI | 81% |
Zhao (2015) [123] | 40 | P/O | 4 | CDAI | 52% |
Yang (2017) [66] | 41 | NE | 12 | CDAI | 80% |
Xue (2018) [124] | 67 | NE | 8 | CDAI | 68% |
Xu (2019) [125] | 104 | NE | H-B | 52% | |
Sharma (2020) [126] | 31 | P/S-E | 2–6 | CDAI | 80% |
Total | 797 | IC (95%) | 60.1% (56.6–63.4) |
CDAI: Crohn’s disease activity index. 1: Clinical trials comparing with drugs. 2: Clinical trials comparing two enteral formulas. E: elemental formula. H-B: Harvey-Bradshaw. NE: not specified. O: oligomeric formula. P: polymeric formula.