Skip to main content
. 2020 Dec 17;11:554915. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2020.554915

Table 6.

Subgroup analysis of working memory (chronic exercises).

Subgroup N SMD 95% conf. interval I2 Test for between-group heterogeneity
Q-value df (Q) p-value
Age
5–12 9 (638) −0.64 −0.87, −0.42 47.0% 18.06 1 0.001
12–18 3 (773) −0.30 −0.49, −0.12 12.8%
Type
Open motor skills 5 (419) −0.72 −0.93, −0.43 26.9% 20.53 1 0.001
Close motor skills 5 (386) −0.31 −0.57,−0.25 12.4%
Studies' quality
Scores more than 6 (>6) 6 (884) −0.33 −0.55, −0.21 6.9% 27.89 1 0.001
Scores less than 6 (≤6) 7 (593) −0.86 −1.13, −0.39 0.0%
Duration
More than 12 weeks 6 (336) −0.36 −0.79, −0.15 0.0% 0.16 1 0.694
Less than 12 weeks 7 (1141) −0.62 −0.97,−0.26 82.8%
Composite type
Multiple-exercise intervention 6 (666) −0.58 −1.15, −0.37 48.0% 1.47 1 0.257
Sole-exercise intervention 7 (811) −0.44 −0.83, −0.25 23.2%
Frequency
1–3 times/week 5 (478) −0.40 −0.65, −0.15 21.6% 0.10 1 0.953
4–7 times/week 8 (999) −0.61 −0.61,−0.32 79.6%
Exercise session time
≤30 4 (295) −0.82 −1.01, −0.64 59.5% 18.92 1 0.001
>30 9 (1182) −0.35 −0.47, −0.22 13.1%